The Crusade for Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Might Be Unraveling

A former president of Harvard, Larry Summers, says it aided and abetted antisemitism on college campuses.

AP/Luca Bruno
Lawrence Summers at Venice, Italy, July 9, 2021. AP/Luca Bruno

A former president of Harvard, Larry Summers, is assigning blame to “identity politics” while the “cancer” of antisemitism metastasizes on college campuses.

The campaign for “diversity, equity, and inclusion” in higher education has paradoxically fueled prejudice toward certain groups on campus, Mr. Summers argues in an essay published on his website Monday. Jewish and Israeli students are the victims of such prejudice, he says, as they face a surge in antisemitic incidents that university leaders have been slow to denounce. 

“It is shameful,” the former Treasury secretary writes, “that no honest observer looking at the record of the last few years and especially at the last month can suppose that universities’ responses including Harvard to antisemitism have paralleled in vigor or volume the responses to racism or other forms of prejudice.” 

“Unacceptable” is how Mr. Summers described the “double standards” exposed by university leaders’ responses to anti-Israel rhetoric and behavior across college campuses. “I believe though that those of us concerned with prejudice against Jews make a grave mistake if we embrace the approach of identity politics and seek only to be an equally recognized identity.”

Mr. Summers took aim at “those most directly charged with confronting prejudice” — university offices of diversity, equity, and inclusion. The office bearing that responsibility at Harvard pledges to foster “a place where everyone can thrive” through “inclusive excellence.” It has yet to release a statement, though, responding to any of the political protests that have rocked its campus in recent weeks. 

“There may even have been cases,” Mr. Summers said of these offices, “where they did more to support the prejudiced than victims. Ideologies arising out of identity politics have too often had the effect of driving discrimination against groups whose members have been most committed to the values of rigorous study and intellectual inquiry.”

Since the Israel-Hamas war erupted on October 7, these comments mark Mr. Summers’s most robust statement concerning his alma mater, where he became an economics professor in 1983. Yet he has long been a fearless critic of antisemitism at the nation’s oldest and richest university. 

In a 2002 speech delivered at Memorial Church in the center of campus early in his presidency, Mr. Summers said a petition to divest Harvard’s endowment from Israel would “single out Israel among all nations as the lone country where it is inappropriate for any part of the university’s endowment to be invested.” Proponents of the movement, he said, were “antisemitic in their effect if not their intent.” 

What Mr. Summers now calls “identity politics” engendered the turmoil he sparked in 2005 after suggesting there might be inherent cognitive differences between men and women at a conference on diversifying the science and engineering workforce. Those comments led to a bitter battle waged by Harvard’s Faculty of Arts and Science, which ultimately pushed him out of office. 

“There can be no mistake that this fight is about way more than gender differences,” the Sun argued in an op-ed that year. “The issues swirling around Mr. Summers include the current war against Islamic terror and the struggle for a Jewish state in Israel, and it has become a fight for the soul of America’s oldest and greatest university.”

Nearly two decades later, Mr. Summers is still waging that fight. “We come together at a moment of danger,” he told a crowd at the Harvard Medical and Dental School Shabbat Observance on Friday, where he initially delivered a version of the essay. “Antisemitism is a cancer — a lethal adversary best addressed as rapidly, thoughtfully, and aggressively as possible.”

Harvard’s office of Equity, Diversity, Inclusion & Belonging did not immediately respond to the Sun’s request for comment. 

The New York Sun

© 2023 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  Create a free account

By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use