Washington State Abandons Bid To Force Priests To Break the Seal of Confession

Religious freedom advocates are celebrating a promise by authorities in Washington state not to enforce a portion of a law that would have forced priests to break the seal of confession. Earlier this year, the state passed Senate Bill 5375, which requires priests to report any incident of child abuse, even if they learn of it only through the sacrament. The law provides for penalties of up to 364 days in jail and fines of up to $5,000 for clergy members who do not comply. The law became the subject of lawsuits from Catholic and Orthodox groups over concerns it violated the free exercise clause of the First Amendment.They argued that the law forces priests to violate either the law or their “sacred vows” to keep information learned in confession confidential, risking their careers in the church.In July, a federal judge issued an injunction that blocked enforcement of the law as the litigation proceeded.On Friday, Washington agreed to a settlement in which it promised not to appeal the injunction or to try to enforce the law in cases involving the confessional. The law still makes the reporting of child abuse mandatory for other professionals, including teachers, child care workers, and doctors The law was challenged on behalf of the state’s Catholic bishops and priests by the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, a Washington, D.C.-based nonprofit. The group’s CEO, Mark Rienzi, issued a statement saying the state “was wise to walk away from this draconian law and allow Catholic clergy to continue ministering to the faithful.”“This is a victory for religious freedom and for common sense. Priests should never be forced to make the impossible choice of betraying their sacred vows or going to jail,” Mr. Rienzi said.The executive director of the Washington State Catholic Conference, Jean Hill, said the Catholic Church supported the law’s goal, but wanted a “narrow exemption to protect the sacrament.”“We’re grateful the state ultimately recognized it can prevent abuse without forcing priests to violate their sacred vows,” Ms. Hill said.More than half of the states in America list clergy as mandatory reporters of child abuse. However, all but New Hampshire and West Virginia carve out exemptions for confession. Washington’s law was unique in that it kept in place the attorney-client privilege and similar privileges for certain other professions but not for priests.Catholic priests who complied with the law would face excommunication, according to the Catholic Church’s Code of Canon Law.Clergy members in Orthodox churches can be kicked out of the priesthood if they break the seal of confession to report an incident of child abuse. The decision by lawmakers not to exempt confession while leaving other privileges in place led to allegations that the law was targeting clergy members. The Department of Justice filed a motion to intervene in the lawsuit brought by Catholic bishops. The assistant attorney general in charge of the department’s Civil Rights Division, Harmeet Dhillon, said in a statement, “Laws that explicitly target religious practices such as the Sacrament of Confession in the Catholic Church have no place in our society.”A Democratic state senator who sponsored the legislation, Noel Frame, previously suggested to NPR that churches could “change their rules” to let clergy members comply with the law without facing disciplinary actions.While the law was being debated, the Washington State Catholic Conference argued that “most immediate indicators that a child is being abused” will be found “outside of the confessional.”“What is required to ensure children are protected is adults well-trained to recognize the indicators, not waiting until a confession, which may not come until years later, if at all,” the group said.The lawsuit filed by the bishops insisted that the Catholic Church has stronger requirements for reporting incidents of child abuse than the state’s law.

Washington State Abandons Bid To Force Priests To Break the Seal of Confession

Washington State Abandons Bid To Force Priests To Break the Seal of Confession

More from the New York Sun

Asked About a 2028 Bid, Trump Praises Cruz, Calling Him ‘Talented’ and ‘a Friend’

Democrat Mary Peltola Opens Wide Lead Over Sitting GOP Senator in Initial Round of Alaska Voting

Iran Not Only Targets Barron but Melania Trump, Plots To Assassinate Yair Netanyahu

American Academic Who Leveled Plagiarism Charges Against Cambridge Professor Jason Arday Is Reinstated

Justice Jackson’s Invocation of a ‘Kafkaesque Nightmare’ Proves Too Extreme for Even Her Fellow Liberal Justices

Reckless Overspending Fuels America’s Surging National Debt, Yet Democrats Try To Pin the Blame on Tax Cuts

The World Grows More Dangerous as American Governance Gets More Frivolous

Broadway’s New Season: ‘A Few Good Men,’ a Singing Galileo, and a Dolly Parton Musical

More from the New York Sun

Asked About a 2028 Bid, Trump Praises Cruz, Calling Him ‘Talented’ and ‘a Friend’

Democrat Mary Peltola Opens Wide Lead Over Sitting GOP Senator in Initial Round of Alaska Voting

Iran Not Only Targets Barron but Melania Trump, Plots To Assassinate Yair Netanyahu

American Academic Who Leveled Plagiarism Charges Against Cambridge Professor Jason Arday Is Reinstated

Justice Jackson’s Invocation of a ‘Kafkaesque Nightmare’ Proves Too Extreme for Even Her Fellow Liberal Justices

Reckless Overspending Fuels America’s Surging National Debt, Yet Democrats Try To Pin the Blame on Tax Cuts

The World Grows More Dangerous as American Governance Gets More Frivolous

Broadway’s New Season: ‘A Few Good Men,’ a Singing Galileo, and a Dolly Parton Musical