How the Rise of Experts Fuels the Regulatory State — and the Demise of Common Sense

How did we get to the point where having an old-fashioned seesaw on the playground is something almost no park district would consider? Or that students crossing the street to visit the firehouse must get a signed waiver? Or that a school bus can’t let a 7-year-old off at the bus stop unless there’s an adult waiting there to walk them home half a block?Philip Howard says it all began in the ’60s. Not with the hippies — with the experts. “The idea we had back then was that we could prescribe the correctness of public choices with detailed rules,” says Mr. Howard, author, most recently, of “Saving Can-Do: How to Revive the Spirit of America.”Mr. Howard adds: “But actually, that’s not correct. Practically every situation involves human judgment in the circumstances.”The post-war optimism about technocrats led America to start substituting regulations for what some of us call common sense. It was also the era when any untoward experience started to become a potential lawsuit. This combination, which was supposed to make our world safer and more fair, had the unintended consequence of making it stagnant and scary. Lots of rules meant lots of opportunities for punishment.“Kids can’t go out and play because if they’re unsupervised and somebody had an accident, there might be a lawsuit,” says Mr. Howard. As for seesaws, merry-go-rounds, even tree stumps on the playground, “Anything where kids might fall could create a lawsuit too,” he says. “So the best thing to do is to get rid of them.”The result is not just boring playgrounds. It’s bored children with fewer chances to learn to solve problems. “You no longer have the brain learning these social skills, because you have an adult overseeing them,” says Mr. Howard.Perhaps Mr. Howard’s biggest bugaboo is the burgeoning books of standards that schools and other institutions, like day care centers and nursing homes, are required to follow. The problem with micromanagement from afar is that something that may be dangerous in one situation (walking home from a bus stop along a highway) isn’t dangerous in another (walking home along a quiet street), yet it is prohibited everywhere. And that rule is backed up with the threat that if a child is hurt, however randomly, there is always someone to blame.Administrators, in turn, are forced to think defensively instead of using their own best judgment: If saying no to this activity means no one will ever get hurt, how could I ever say yes?Yet administrators — and teachers, doctors and all of us who have done our jobs for a while — have learned things. We have absorbed lessons. We have observed reality. And we should be able to make decisions based on what we KNOW but can’t necessarily PROVE.This, too, has become taboo, says Mr. Howard. Even though wisdom is what you get from experience, we are not allowed to form our own ideas of what is sensible and safe enough. We are forced, instead, to comply.And when we are busy trying to make sure that we have done things exactly as outlined on page 78, subparagraph 5-H, we’re not getting smarter. “The regulatory state is literally mind-numbing,” Mr. Howard says. Load it up with rules and it can’t see the slide as anything other than a piece of equipment that is noncompliant, should it angle more than 43 degrees in a vertical direction.Mr. Howard believes one solution to this state of affairs could be a “Risk Commission” that, perhaps like this Social Policy Report piece, lays out what risks are appropriate — even crucial — for children at different ages. The findings would be based on child development, not risk aversion. It would be backup for parents and schools who want to let their tots do more on their own. And the people on that commission?They’d be allowed to use their judgment.Creators.com

How the Rise of Experts Fuels the Regulatory State — and the Demise of Common Sense

How the Rise of Experts Fuels the Regulatory State — and the Demise of Common Sense

More from the New York Sun

Paramount and Warner Bros. — the Foreign State Problem

Communist China, Seeking To Erase America’s Lead in AI, Takes a Page From Soviet Union’s Atomic Playbook

Liberal Powerplays Take Center Stage as Legal Battle Grows Between Mamdani, City Council Over Pay Bumps for Teachers’ Aides

RFK Jr. Launches New Federal Autism Research Program

JD Vance To Host Shabbat Dinner as He Seeks To Woo Jewish Voters Amid 2028 Buzz

Le Pen Denounces Trump for ‘Setting the Whole Planet Ablaze’ With Iran War

To Reverse Persistent Inflation, Congress Will Need To Tame Rampant Federal Overspending

Doctors Objected To One-Year-Old Being Euthanized In Netherlands

More from the New York Sun

Paramount and Warner Bros. — the Foreign State Problem

Communist China, Seeking To Erase America’s Lead in AI, Takes a Page From Soviet Union’s Atomic Playbook

Liberal Powerplays Take Center Stage as Legal Battle Grows Between Mamdani, City Council Over Pay Bumps for Teachers’ Aides

RFK Jr. Launches New Federal Autism Research Program

JD Vance To Host Shabbat Dinner as He Seeks To Woo Jewish Voters Amid 2028 Buzz

Le Pen Denounces Trump for ‘Setting the Whole Planet Ablaze’ With Iran War

To Reverse Persistent Inflation, Congress Will Need To Tame Rampant Federal Overspending

Doctors Objected To One-Year-Old Being Euthanized In Netherlands