Howard Keel, 85, Star of MGM Musicals and ‘Dallas’

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

Howard Keel, the broad-shouldered baritone who romanced his way through a series of glittery MGM musicals such as “Kiss Me Kate” and “Annie Get Your Gun” and later revived his career with television’s “Dallas,” died Sunday of colon cancer. He was 85.


Keel starred in Rodgers and Hammerstein musicals in New York and London before being signed to an MGM contract after World War II. The timing was perfect: He became a star with his first MGM film, playing Frank Butler to Betty Hutton’s Annie Oakley in “Annie Get Your Gun.”


Keel’s size and lusty voice made him an ideal leading man for such stars as Esther Williams (“Pagan Love Song,” “Texas Carnival,” “Jupiter’s Darling”), Ann Blyth (“Rose Marie,” “Kismet”), Kathryn Grayson (“Show Boat,” “Lovely to Look At,” “Kiss Me Kate”), and Doris Day (“Calamity Jane”).


His own favorite film was the exuberant “Seven Brides for Seven Brothers.”


“It was a fine cast and lots of fun to make,” Keel remarked in 1993, “but they did the damn thing on the cheap. The backdrops had holes in them, and it was shot on the worst film stock. …As it turned out, the miracle worker was George Folsey, the cinematographer. He took that junk and made it look like a Grandma Moses painting.”


When film studios went into a slump, MGM’s musical factory was disbanded. Keel kept busy on the road in such surefire attractions as “Man of La Mancha,” “South Pacific,” “Annie Get Your Gun,” and “Seven Brides for Seven Brothers.”


Keel was 66 and presumably nearing the end of his career when he suddenly became a star in another medium.


From its start in 1978, “Dallas,” with its combination of oil, greed, sex, and duplicity, had become the hottest series in television. Jim Davis, who had played the role of Jock Ewing, died in 1981, and the producers needed another strong presence to stand up to the nefarious J.R. Ewing Jr. (Larry Hagman).They chose Keel.


“The show was enormous,” Keel reflected in 1995.”I couldn’t believe it. My life changed again. From being out of it, I was suddenly a star, known to more people than ever before. Wherever I went, crowds appeared again, and I started making solo albums for the first time.”


As Clayton Farlow, husband of “Miss Ellie” Ewing (Barbara Bel Geddes), Keel remained with “Dallas” until it folded in 1991.


When Keel was born in Gillespie, Ill., his name was Harold Clifford Leek. His father, once a naval captain, became a coal miner and drank to soothe his bitterness. During drunken rages, he beat his children. His mother, a strict Methodist, forbade her two sons from having any entertainment.


“I had a terrible, rotten childhood,” Keel commented in 1995. “My father made away with himself when I was 11. I had no guidance, and Mom was six feet tall, bucktoothed and very tough. I was mean and rebellious and had a terrible, bitter temper. I got a job as an auto mechanic, and I would have stayed in that narrow kind of life if I hadn’t discovered art. Music changed me completely.”


At 20 he was living in Los Angeles and happened to attend a Hollywood Bowl concert featuring famed baritone Lawrence Tibbett. Keel was inspired, and he started taking vocal lessons at 25 cents an hour. His first semiprofessional opportunity came as a singing waiter at the Paris Inn Restaurant in downtown Los Angeles at $15 a week and two meals a day.


Six foot three and a gawky 140 pounds, Keel was painfully shy. He sang in recitals and opera programs and was summoned to an audition with Oscar Hammerstein II, who was looking for young singers to play Curly in the growing number of touring “Oklahoma!” companies.


Hammerstein approved, and soon, under a new name, Howard Keel was singing “Oh, What a Beautiful Morning” in New York eight times a week. He sometimes replaced John Raitt in Rodgers and Hammerstein’s other hit, “Carousel.” On occasion, he would appear in a matinee of “Oklahoma!” and an evening performance of “Carousel.” He played “Carousel” for 18 months in London.


Rodgers and Hammerstein were notorious for underpaying their actors and denying them billing. Keel rankled at being paid $250 a week for the unbilled starring role in a sell-out musical. As soon as his contract expired, he hurried back to Los Angeles. Desperately in need of handsome, virile actors who could sing, MGM signed Keel to a contract that paid $850 a week.


He made it big in musicals but also appeared in westerns: “Waco,” “Red Tomahawk,” and “The War Wagon” (with John Wayne and Kirk Douglas), as well as other films, such as “The Day of the Triffids,” a mediocre 1962 alien invasion flick. He continued singing in his 80s, explaining: “As long as I can sing halfway decent, I’d rather sing (than act).There’s nothing like being in good voice, feeling good, having good numbers to do and having a fine orchestra.”


The New York Sun

© 2024 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  Create a free account

or
By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use