The backers of what would have been the country’s first tax-funded religious virtual charter school are promising to fight the Oklahoma supreme court’s decision that blocks it, in a case that has sparked a national religious freedom debate.&nbsp;



St. Isidore of Seville Catholic Virtual School had been set to open this year and aimed to provide education centered around the “Catholic Intellectual Tradition” to students of any faith background. Yet the Oklahoma supreme court shot it down in June, ordering the state’s virtual charter school board that approved the school’s contract to rescind it, following a lawsuit from the state’s attorney general, Gentner Drummond. The justices held that the religious charter school was unconstitutional and created a “slippery slope.”&nbsp;



St. Isidore is promising to “fight” the state supreme court’s decision, and a representative of the school confirmed to the Sun that it intends to seek the U.S. Supreme Court’s review.&nbsp;



Mr. Drummond, for his part, has said that as the case is “sure to be appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court,” he will keep fighting it. He argues that taxpayers shouldn’t be forced to fund schools that teach religions they don’t agree with, and repeatedly expressed concerns that allowing a Catholic charter school could lead to tax-funded schools that promote “the radical teachings of Sharia or the demonic worship of Satan.”



The state’s new charter school board — which succeeds the virtual charter school board that approved St. Isidore’s contract — met Monday to discuss the future of St. Isidore’s, the board’s agenda <a href="https://oklahoma.gov/scsb/about-us/board-meetings.html">indicates</a>.



As the school plans to appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court, the justices in recent rulings have signaled a less restrictive stance on the First Amendment’s establishment clause and a more robust interpretation of the free exercise clause. In 2017, in Trinity Lutheran Church of Columbia v. Comer, the court <a href="https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/19pdf/18-1195_g314.pdf">held</a> that “denying a generally available benefit solely on account of religious identity imposes a penalty on the free exercise of religion.” 



In Espinoza v. Montana Department of Revenue, a 2020 ruling, the court said the state cannot block parents from using public scholarship funds at religious schools. In 2022, the <a href="https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/21pdf/20-1088_dbfi.pdf">court</a> held in Carson v. Makin that religious schools couldn’t be excluded from “generally available tuition assistance payments.”&nbsp;



Despite the anticipated Supreme Court appeal, some observers say it’s a long shot that the high court would weigh in.



“I would not expect the Supreme Court to take this up, first and foremost because the court rejects the vast majority of petitions it receives to hear cases,” the Cato Institute’s Center for Educational Freedom director, Neal McCluskey, tells the Sun. “At least until we see more charter school cases like this one, I think the Supreme Court will leave this alone.”



He said the Oklahoma school case is different from Espinoza and Carson because those cases “dealt with programs allowing families to use publicly connected funds at private schools the families chose, while the Oklahoma case involves government granting a charter to a school to make it a public school.”&nbsp;



“The justices might still be sympathetic to the argument that religious institutions should not be singled out for exclusion from chartering, but establishing religious public schools is substantially different from allowing people to freely choose private religious institutions,” he adds.&nbsp;



Although the realm of virtual religious charter schools is a new front, he points out that public schools throughout much of American history “tended to be de facto religious,” especially with Protestant schools that incorporated Bible readings and prayer.&nbsp;



“Early in our history we also saw governments provide assistance for religious schools of various denominations,” he says, adding that “during the Founding period the primary educational concern was forming virtuous citizens, which was directly connected to religion.”



Yet, the Founders may have been concerned with the state creating a Catholic school, he says.&nbsp;



“The Catholic Church was seen very much as an enemy of a republican country,” he says of the Founding era. “It is not seen that way anymore, at least not broadly, but it raises the same problem as the Shariah and Satanism concerns: Should government be in the position to say which religious schools are acceptable and which are not?”&nbsp;

The Oklahoma supreme court in the state capitol building at Oklahoma City.

Future of Nation’s First Tax-Funded Catholic Charter School Might Fall on Supreme Court

After the school was shot down, the state’s charter school board is figuring out next steps.

Future of Nation’s First Tax-Funded Catholic Charter School Might Fall on Supreme Court | The New York Sun

Home

The New York Sun

https://wp.nysun.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/the-new-york-sun-og.jpg

A Boeing aircraft that President Trump toured amid concerns about delays of the new Air Force One takes off from Palm Beach International Airport on February 16, 2025.

Qatargate: Now an Ultra-Luxurious Jumbo Jet for President Trump’s Use

For more than an hour on 'The View' on May 8, President Biden defended his record and his decision to run for re-election. 

Biden, Dreading Tell-Alls on His Faculties, Reaches for an Outdated Playbook

Speaker Johnson leaves the House chamber at the Capitol at Washington, April 9, 2025. 

House Republicans Slug It Out Over Tax Cuts, Price Tag in Trump’s ‘One Big Beautiful Bill’

A woman holds a banner during a rally against the breakup of the country back in 2014.

Crimea, Exhausted by Conflict and Being Used as Political Football, Is Focusing on What It Wants From Its Future

President Trump boards Air Force One at Joint Base Andrews.

White House and China Announce Tariff Reduction Plan Ahead of Trump’s Four-Day Trip to Arab Gulf States

(L-R) Brigham Buhler, Jillian Michael and Robert F. Kennedy Jr.

Big Pharma Is Winning the Price War Over Weight Loss Drugs Like Ozempic: Will RFK Jr. and His MAHA Allies Push Back? 

President Trump signs an executive order during an event in the East Room of the White House, April 8, 2025, at Washington.

Trump and His Inner Circle Are Entertaining Something a Critic Calls ‘Nuts’: Suspension of Habeas Corpus To Jump-Start Deportations

Afrikaner refugees from South Africa holding American flags arrive, Monday, May 12, 2025, at Dulles International Airport.

Citing Racial Bias by Trump Administration, Episcopal Church Opts Out of Federal Refugee Resettlement Funding Rather Than Accept White South Africans

Future of Nation’s First Tax-Funded Catholic Charter School Might Fall on Supreme Court

To continue reading, please select:

Enter your email to read for FREE

Join the Sun for a PENNY A DAY

Sections

More

Sign in or create a free account

A login link has been sent to