FDA Says Cloned Animals Safe for Food

WASHINGTON — Meat and milk from cloned animals is as safe as that from their counterparts bred the old-fashioned way, the Food and Drug Administration said today.The decision removes the last American regulatory hurdle to marketing products from cloned cows, pigs, and goats, and puts the FDA in concert with recent safety assessments from European food regulators and several other nations.“The data show that healthy adult clones are virtually indistinguishable” from their counterparts, concludes FDA’s 900-plus page safety report.But for economic reasons, it will be years before many foods from cloned animals reach store shelves. At between $10,000 and $20,000 an animal, they’re a lot more expensive than ordinary cows. That means producers likely will us clones’ offspring for meat, not the clones themselves.In addition, several large food companies — including dairy giant Dean Foods Co. and Hormel Foods Corp. — have said they have no plans to sell milk or meat from cloned animals, because of consumer anxiety about the technology.The two main American cloning companies, Viagen Inc. and Trans Ova Genetics, already have produced more than 600 cloned animals for American breeders, including copies of prize-winning cows and rodeo bulls.“We certainly are pleased,” the president of Trans Ova, David Faber, said.“Our farmer and rancher clients are pleased because it provided them with another reproductive tool,” he added.Food producers have voluntarily withheld cloned animals from the market pending FDA’s decision, and it wasn’t immediately clear today if that moratorium was ending immediately — or if other government agencies must weigh in first.The ruling was long-expected — and mirrors FDA’s initial safety assessment back in 2003 — but highly controversial nonetheless. Debate has been fierce within the Bush administration as to whether the FDA should move forward, largely because of trade concerns. Consumer advocates petitioned against the move, and Congress had passed legislation urging the FDA to study the economic ramifications before moving ahead.It was a day forecast since 1997, when Scottish scientists announced they had successfully cloned Dolly the sheep. Ironically, sheep aren’t on the list of FDA’s approved cloned animals; the agency said there wasn’t as much data about their safety as about cows, pigs, and goats.By its very definition, a successfully cloned animal should be no different from the original animal whose DNA was used to create it.But the technology hasn’t been perfected — and many attempts at livestock cloning still end in fatal birth defects or with deformed fetuses dying in the womb. Moreover, Dolly was euthanized in 2003, well short of her normal lifespan, because of a lung disease that raised questions about how cloned animals will age.The FDA’s report acknowledges that, “Currently, it is not possible to draw any conclusions regarding the longevity of livestock clones or possible long-term health consequences” for the animal.But the agency concluded that cloned animals that are born healthy are no different from their non-cloned counterparts, and go on to reproduce normally as well.

FDA Says Cloned Animals Safe for Food

FDA Says Cloned Animals Safe for Food

More from the New York Sun

The Lights Go Out on St. Barts

By All Means, Bust ‘Decoy Dan’ Dirty Tricks, but Remember the Foundational Battle Between Socialist Misery and Free Enterprise Prosperity

Police Enter Poland’s Top Court, Head of Court Suspended in Battle for Control

Ramaswamy Pulls Divisive Ad Featuring His Democratic Opponent’s Mother as Polls Indicate It Backfired

The Papal Vote

North Korea Hackers Blamed for Audacious $6 Billion Crypto Theft

Carney Starts Process to Join European Union as ‘Associate Member’

Christa Pike Issues First Public Statement After Botched Execution, Bemoans Physical and Mental ‘Pain’

More from the New York Sun

The Lights Go Out on St. Barts

By All Means, Bust ‘Decoy Dan’ Dirty Tricks, but Remember the Foundational Battle Between Socialist Misery and Free Enterprise Prosperity

Police Enter Poland’s Top Court, Head of Court Suspended in Battle for Control

Ramaswamy Pulls Divisive Ad Featuring His Democratic Opponent’s Mother as Polls Indicate It Backfired

The Papal Vote

North Korea Hackers Blamed for Audacious $6 Billion Crypto Theft

Carney Starts Process to Join European Union as ‘Associate Member’

Christa Pike Issues First Public Statement After Botched Execution, Bemoans Physical and Mental ‘Pain’