A Federal Judge Rebukes Kristi Noem on Immigration Law and Protected Status for Haitians

Shrill but useful — useful because she is so shrill — Kristi Noem has elicited from a federal judge a valuable 83-page tutorial. The secretary of homeland security, her mind as closed as a clam, will not benefit from Judge Ana Reyes’s explanation of immigration law. Other Americans will.On December 1, Mrs. Noem shared on X this thought: “I am recommending a full travel ban on every damn country that’s been flooding our nation with killers, leeches, and entitlement junkies” who “slaughter our heroes, suck dry our hard-earned tax dollars, or snatch the benefits owed to AMERICANS. WE DON’T WANT THEM. NOT ONE.” This was three days after Mrs. Noem officially “determined” that she would terminate, effective February 3, temporary protected status for about 353,000 Haitians who have found refuge here.Last Monday, Judge Reyes, of the United States District Court for the District of Columbia, the nation’s second-most important court, blocked Mrs. Noem’s order. Judge Reyes said the process that produced it was so riddled with lawlessness that the plaintiffs would likely prevail in a trial.The five Haitian plaintiffs include a neuroscientist researching Alzheimer’s disease, a national bank’s software engineer, a laboratory assistant in a toxicology department, a college economics major and a full-time registered nurse. No leeches joined the suit.The Trump administration argues (as it does regarding the president’s declaration of an “emergency” justifying tariffs) that Mrs. Noem’s exercise of discretion is not subject to judicial review. Judge Reyes, however, eviscerates what she calls Mrs. Noem’s claim to “unbounded discretion to make whatever determination she wants, any way she wants.” Judge Reyes says her court would indeed lack jurisdiction were the plaintiffs challenging Mrs. Noem’s determination, but they are challenging how she made it.Judge Reyes says Congress meticulously detailed a temporary protected status process “to replace executive whim with statutory predictability.” Mrs. Noem’s chaotic rationalizations for her action scream that they are pretexts for a predetermined policy. (She has terminated all 12 TPS country designations that have reached her desk. Judge Reyes calls this unprecedented in the 35 years since the TPS program was established.)Naturally, Mrs. Noem says ending TPS will serve “national security” by somehow making it easier for “federal officials” to assess threats from “aliens attempting to enter the U.S. illegally.” Judge Reyes dryly says: “But TPS holders are already in the country.” And, Judge Reyes notes, Mrs. Noem’s withdrawal of TPS would burden the immigration system by turning the 353,000 “lawful immigrants into unlawful ones overnight.”Mrs. Noem ignored the statute’s stipulation that she review conditions in Haiti “after” consulting with appropriate government agencies. Instead, Mrs. Noem made her decision, then conducted a contemptuously perfunctory consultation. The law requires consultations with other agencies — plural. Her consultation consisted of a Department of Homeland Security staffer sending a two-sentence email to a State Department staffer, whose one-sentence reply, 53 minutes later, said Mrs. Noem’s policy is fine.“Congress,” Judge Reyes says, “did not vest the Secretary with Humpty Dumpty-like power to make the word ‘consultation’ mean ‘just what [she] chooses it to mean – neither more nor less.’” Mrs. Noem shrugged off the statutory requirement of what Judge Reyes calls a “good-faith, fact-based, country-specific review.”Since 2010, severe earthquakes and hurricanes have exacerbated Haiti’s preexisting vulnerabilities. (Forty-five percent of Haitians already were undernourished, and 30 percent of children under 5 suffered chronic malnutrition.) Today, Haiti is a Hobbesian, gang-riven, cholera-menaced state of nature where life often is “solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short.”President Trump has said Haitians “all have AIDS.” His secretary of state says Americans should avoid Haiti like the plague. Mrs. Noem, however, blithely says “parts of the country” are “suitable” for the 353,000 to return to. She identified no part.Judge Reyes says the plaintiffs “are likely to succeed on their claim that anti-black and anti-Haitian animus” motivated Mrs. Noem. She is, after all, theatrically abject in her subservience to a president who says illegal immigrants (TPS holders are legally here) are “poisoning the blood” of America, are “snakes,” “garbage,” “not people” and have “bad genes.” He says he prefers immigrants from “nice” countries like Norway, Sweden and Denmark. He has said Haitian immigration is “like a death wish for our country.” He has imposed travel restrictions on 19 countries, all of them predominantly non-White.Ascribing racial animus to Mrs. Noem, via the president she serves, is facially plausible but legally superfluous. Her TPS action is illegitimate because it is arbitrary, capricious and lawless. Yet her eagerness to send 353,000 into a maelstrom of disease, poverty, violence (including sexual violence) and death will not — cannot — further lower her stature.The Washington Post

A Federal Judge Rebukes Kristi Noem on Immigration Law and Protected Status for Haitians

More from the New York Sun

Moment of Truth Approaches for Trump’s Supreme Court Appeal of $5 Million ‘Sexual Abuse’ and ‘Defamation’ Verdict in E. Jean Carroll Case

Jimmy Lai’s Sentence Bares Threat to Free China

FBI Releases Unsettling Images and Video of Heavily Disguised Suspect in Nancy Guthrie Kidnapping

More from the New York Sun

Moment of Truth Approaches for Trump’s Supreme Court Appeal of $5 Million ‘Sexual Abuse’ and ‘Defamation’ Verdict in E. Jean Carroll Case

Jimmy Lai’s Sentence Bares Threat to Free China

FBI Releases Unsettling Images and Video of Heavily Disguised Suspect in Nancy Guthrie Kidnapping

‘Simply Unacceptable’: Anti-Israel Mob Clashes With Australian Police During Israeli President’s Visit

U.S. Rejects West Bank Annexation as Israel Expands Control in Territory

Olympic Legend Sees 1968 Again Amid Uproar Over Team USA Athletes Questioning America

Evanston Considers Adding Additional Taxes To Fund Cash-Strapped Reparations Program

Oklahoma Board Rejects Application From a Jewish Charter School, Teeing Up a Possible Supreme Court Do-Over on Religious Charter Schools