Lost Between Heaven and Hell

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

“The Bothersome Man,” by the Norwegian director Jens Lien, resembles an episode of “The Twilight Zone,” but with better production values. In fact, I seem to remember a “Twilight Zone” episode that told a very similar story. Also as in “The Twilight Zone,” the film seems to have been designed to get people talking around the office water cooler.

Is it heaven, this antiseptic, blue-gray world in which our hero, Andreas (Trond Fausa Aurvåg), suddenly finds himself welcomed with a job, a home, a girlfriend — a perfect life? Or is it hell?

Or is it, perhaps, all happening in the utopia of some parallel universe where death, along with love and its consequences — children, passion, jealousy, and heartbreak, — have all been abolished, as have the ability to get drunk or to taste food?

Or is it all a parable about the consumer paradise and Prozac Nation?

And then there’s the question of why Andreas has no memory, apparently, of where he came from or how he got to this place. Why does he alone appear to feel anything except bland well-being? Why does he become a dissident, the bothersome man of the title, desperate to reach the comforts and discomforts of reality when everyone else seems so happy with unreality?

And what about the really weird ending? Where and in what condition are we supposed to think Andreas ends up?

Of course, if there were answers to any of these questions, there wouldn’t be anything for people to talk about — at the water-cooler or anywhere else. Mere speculation would have to give way to something more substantive.

There is something a bit too self-conscious about this “Twilight Zone” style. It’s like the Fat Boy in Dickens who always wanted to “make your flesh creep.” The story that really makes your flesh creep is the one in which the storyteller doesn’t already know it’s creepy. In the same way, the comedian pretends not to know what he’s saying is funny. It spoils the effect if he laughs at his own joke.

All that having been said, I have to add that I quite enjoyed “The Bothersome Man ,” which, among its other virtues, recognizes that, without death, life is an endless black comedy. And how scary is that?

The scene in which Andreas attempts suicide by throwing himself under a train is pure slapstick. He is hit and run over again and again. We hear a sickening crunch and a scream, and then, after he has been tossed about like a rag doll, he gets up and walks out of the train tunnel, covered in blood. A couple of the city’s caretakers come by in one of their electric cars and take him home. There, he is greeted by his girlfriend (Petronella Barker) who, with her unvarying equanimity, tells him that the Nordbys have asked them to go go-carting on Saturday. Does he want to go?

The camera cuts to Andreas, wrapped in a blanket and looking like the mangled corpse he would be in reality. “It sounds nice,” he says.

And then, to complete the joke, we cut to Saturday and Andreas behind the wheel of his go-cart looking particularly silly with his crash helmet on and with no remaining traces of his injuries.

We get the idea that this world is one of perfect stasis and equilibrium. No one is going anywhere. So then the narrative energy is supplied by Andreas’s discovery of a wormhole to reality in a neglected basement from which music can be heard and delicious smells occasionally waft.

Andreas and a dubious associate (Per Schaaning) try to enlarge the hole with a jackhammer until they can climb through it to what, for a brief moment we can see, is more like our world. There are warm colors and music, the sounds of children playing, and a tray of cakes — cakes you can taste — on a kitchen counter.

Managing only to snatch a cake and devour it wolfishly, Andreas is caught and dragged back to the blue-gray world by the ever-efficient caretakers. It is suggested that more people than just he are unhappy about being so happy, and want, as he does, to escape to reality. But nobody else dares say so, let alone do anything about it. Why or how are they induced to disavow their desires? We are never told. Andreas remains the lone dissident, the one bothersome man. Presumably, happiness of this bland kind is a sort of drug on which people get hooked. They dream occasionally of a life without it, but they haven’t the strength or the will to pursue it.

It would help if Andreas’s fate revealed what happens to them if they do. But “The Bothersome Man” does give us something to speculate about around the water cooler.


The New York Sun

© 2025 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  Create a free account

or
By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use