Accepting Loss Gives Chavez A More Democratic Image

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

CARACAS, Venezuela — In gracefully accepting his first electoral defeat, President Chavez is casting himself as a true democrat and deflecting charges of despotism from Washington and critics at home. But the Venezuelan president is not pulling back from his socialist agenda, and his opponents — for now — have neither the cohesion nor the clout to stop him.

Mr. Chavez narrowly lost a constitutional referendum Sunday that would have enabled him to run for re-election indefinitely and drive changes throughout Venezuelan society.

Some leaders might react to such a setback by toning down their rhetoric and adopting a more moderate approach to woo their citizens. Not Mr. Chavez.

“I want you all to know I’m not withdrawing a single comma of this proposal,” a sober and introspective Mr. Chavez said early yesterday as he conceded defeat. “I will continue making this proposal to the Venezuelan people. The proposal is still alive.”

Even without the constitutional overhaul he had hoped for, Mr. Chavez already has far-reaching authority to single-handedly reshape the government, the economy and society.

He wields special powers granted by the National Assembly this year to enact laws by decree in areas from the economy to the justice system.

Those powers, which remain in effect until mid-2008, could enable Mr. Chavez to restructure state institutions, raise taxes on the rich, and adapt existing legislation to share Venezuela’s oil wealth more equitably in what he calls “21st-century socialism.”

Though a pragmatist at times, Mr. Chavez’s conflict-prone, larger-than-life personality leaves little room for compromise, ensuring more friction in a country now deeply polarized by his vision of a socialist utopia.

Mr. Chavez blamed his loss on low turnout among his supporters, even as many poor and working class Venezuelans continue to see their leader as a savior.

“He’s a man who doesn’t want to see his people suffer,” Carlos Orlando Vega, 47, who received his home from Mr. Chavez’s government, said.

But others who previously backed Mr. Chavez were less forgiving of rampant crime, corruption, and shortages of basic supplies such as milk.

And some feared the implications of the 69 proposed constitutional changes, which included indefinite decree power for the president to make changes in the economy, new forms of communal property, and the ability to detain citizens without charge during states of emergency.

“I refuse to be part of a communist regime,” Cecilia Goldberger, a 56-year-old housewife, said.

A narrow victory could have opened Mr. Chavez to accusations of forcing reforms on a dissenting public. Mr. Chavez acknowledged as much, saying: “I wouldn’t have wanted that Pyrrhic victory.”

But the reforms mainly would have given constitutional legitimacy to changes that Mr. Chavez is pushing through anyway. For example, one change would have let the government occupy property it plans to expropriate even before a court rules. Mr. Chavez’s government already has done this in some cases, seizing buildings and land.

Since the opposition boycotted 2005 elections, the National Assembly has been filled almost entirely with Chavez-allied lawmakers. Pro-Chavez governors and mayors have seen their fortunes rise, and the opposition accuses Mr. Chavez’s supporters of loading the courts with biased judges. But Sunday’s victory has energized the opposition. And opponents still has some ways of holding Mr. Chavez accountable, including private news outlets and the possibility of petitioning for a recall referendum once Mr. Chavez reaches the midpoint of his six-year term in December 2009.

With his constitutional overhaul defeated, Mr. Chavez now has to step down in 2013. But if anything characterizes him, it is his staying power. The 53-year-old former army lieutenant colonel told supporters before the vote he would stay in office as long as they wanted — and perhaps “until the last bone of my skeleton dries up.”

Like most of Mr. Chavez’s aims, it is a grand vision he may not easily relinquish.


The New York Sun

© 2024 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  create a free account

By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use