Bin Laden Audiotape a Signal of Relevance

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

CAIRO, Egypt – His message seemed aimed at moderate Arabs, a call to arms that they should support Al Qaeda in fighting what he calls a war against Islam.


But even another terrorist group, Hamas, tried to distance itself after Osama bin Laden’s latest audiotape of threats was aired yesterday on Arab television. Independent analysts said it appears Mr. bin Laden has begun timing such appeals to ensure he stays relevant and in the spotlight.


“If you look back at what’s been happening with bin Laden tapes in the past, it’s when people have kind of forgotten about him, when he’s not been on the news, that the tapes emerge,” a security expert with the Chatham House think tank in London, Bob Ayers, said. “It’s kind of his way of thumbing his nose at the U.S. and saying, ‘Hey, I’m still out here.'”


Yet those who say the connection between Mr. bin Laden’s tapes and actual attacks has ebbed still view them as ominous warnings of Al Qaeda’s overall strategy.


The chairman of the House Intelligence Committee, Rep. Peter Hoekstra, a Republican of Michigan, said Al Qaeda’s propaganda techniques “would make a politician proud.


“It recognizes that much of this war, this battle that we’re fighting, is about winning the hearts and the minds of moderate Islam, and they are focused on that,” Mr. Hoekstra said on “Fox News Sunday.” “We need to be focused on it.”


In the tape, broadcast on Al-Jazeera television, Mr. bin Laden accused average Westerners of supporting a war on Islam and urged his followers to go to Sudan – his former base – to fight a proposed U.N. peacekeeping force.


His words, the first new message in three months, seemed designed to justify potential attacks on civilians – something Al Qaeda has been criticized for even by Arab supporters. He also appeared to be trying to drum up support among Arabs by accusing the West of targeting a terrorist group that fights against Israel and now heads the Palestinian Arab government, Hamas.


Citing the West’s decision to cut off aid to the Hamas-led government, the Al Qaeda leader said Washington and Europe were conducting “a Zionist, crusaders’ war on Islam.”


Al Qaeda is believed to have no direct links to Hamas, which is an outgrowth of the Muslim Brotherhood. And a Hamas spokesman, Sami Abu Zuhri, was quick to distance the group, declaring yesterday that “the ideology of Hamas is totally different from the ideology of Sheik bin Laden.”


The groups do, however, share an anti-Israel ideology that calls for the destruction of the Jewish state. And recent reports in the Middle East media have said Al Qaeda is trying to build cells in Gaza, the West Bank, Lebanon, and Sudan. Israel has indicted two West Bank militants for Al Qaeda membership.


An Israeli government spokesman, Raanan Gissin, said it appeared Mr. bin Laden had decided to issue the verbal assault to deflect growing Arab animosity toward Al Qaeda.


That criticism came to a peak last December when the leader of the Al Qaeda in Iraq group claimed responsibility for bombings of Jordan hotels that killed many Arabs.


“This is something the Arab world can agree upon,” Mr. Gissin said. “He has been criticized for the destruction and carnage he’s causing the Muslim nation. He’s looking for another justification. … Criticizing Israel sounds more politically correct.”


The voice on the tape sounded strong and appeared the same as that on other recordings attributed to Mr. bin Laden. But independent verification was not immediately possible.


Mr. bin Laden’s remarks, which appeared to have been edited heavily by Al-Jazeera, ranged across the spectrum of issues that anger even moderate Arabs. Many of them see a renewal of a Christian- and Jewish-inspired Western “crusade” to dominate the Islamic world and to confiscate Muslim lands and resources – oil in particular.


America’s ambassador to Iraq, Zalmay Khalilzad, downplayed the significance of the message in an interview with CNN’s “Late Edition with Wolf Blitzer.”


“He wants to be relevant to the situation,” Mr. Khalilzad said. “[He] wants to get attention, [to show] that he still is a player and that this is unfinished business that we still have to deal with.”


A senior analyst with a risk assessment consultancy, Control Risks Group, Kevin Rosser, said such tapes “used to be seen as significant because they were thought to contain coded messages or warn of imminent attacks. … As time has gone on, that connection has loosened to the point where these messages are [now] seen as an attempt to reinsert himself into the debate.”


On Sudan, Mr. bin Laden called on his supporters “to prepare for a long war against the crusader plunderers in Western Sudan. Our goal is not defending the Khartoum government but to defend Islam, its land and its people,” he said.


“I urge holy warriors to be acquainted with the land and the tribes in Darfur,” he said, adding they should be aware that the rainy season approaches and that will hamper their movement.


Al Qaeda has targeted Western military forces in Africa before – including its attacks against American troops trying to bring peace to Somalia in 1993.


The fighting in Darfur began when rebels from black African tribes took up arms in February 2003, complaining of discrimination and oppression by Sudan’s Arab-dominated government.


The government has been accused of unleashing Arab tribal militia known as the Janjaweed against civilians in a campaign of murder, rape, and arson. At least 180,000 people have died – many from hunger and disease – and 2 million people have been displaced in the vast, arid region of western Sudan and as refuges in neighboring Chad.


The American and other Western countries are pushing for the United Nations to send a peacekeeping force to the ravaged region.


Mr. bin Laden also a personal background in Sudan – the Saudi-born Al Qaeda leader set up headquarters there after he was forced to leave his homeland. Sudan then expelled him under threats from America.


Mr. bin Laden then moved to Afghanistan where he trained fighters and organized the September 11, 2001, attacks.


He is now believed hiding in the rugged mountains on the Pakistani side of that country’s long border with Afghanistan.


In Washington, American intelligence officials said Mr. bin Laden was now living separately from his top deputy and, in a sign he has to be careful about whom he trusts, surrounded by fellow Arabs.


His no. 2, Ayman al-Zawahri, is hiding in a more settled area along the border, also surrounded by Al Qaeda operatives who share his Egyptian nationality, the officials said on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to release the information.


The Al Qaeda chieftain, who last issued a message broadcast by Al-Jazeera on January 19, also made a point of trying to justify attacks on civilians. He said citizens of Western countries were equally responsible with their governments for what he termed the “war on Islam.”


“I say that this war is the joint responsibility of the people and the governments. While the war continues, the people renew their allegiance to their rulers and politicians and continue to send their sons to our countries to fight us,” Mr. bin Laden said.


In his last message, Mr. bin Laden offered America a long-term truce but warned Al Qaeda would soon launch a fresh attack on American soil. There have been no new attacks on America in the three months since, however.


The New York Sun

© 2025 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  create a free account

or
By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use