Poll: Americans Reach New Level of Discontent Over Iraq War

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

BOSTON — The American public has abandoned President Bush on the Iraq war and is looking to Congress for a way out that includes a timetable for withdrawing American troops, according to a Bloomberg/Los Angeles Times poll.

The national survey shows a disaffected public that has grown sourer about the conflict since September, with only about one in seven believing Mr. Bush’s claim that America is winning in Iraq.

More than half of Americans want to set a schedule to withdraw all troops, a significant change from September, when 44% said America should stay as long as it takes. “There is a new level of discontent” over the war, said Susan Pinkus, the Times polling director. “It’s hurting the economy, and it’s hurting other issues. This is all the president can concentrate on.”

By better than 2-to-1 margins, the public supports two key recommendations of an independent bipartisan panel called the Iraq Study Group. The panel’s report called for direct American negotiations with Iran and Syria about the future of Iraq and possibly withholding economic and military support from the Iraqi government unless it makes progress on political reforms and national reconciliation.

With almost two-thirds saying Iraq is in a civil war, the public’s top priority for the next Congress is setting a timetable for withdrawal. By 62% to 35%, Americans disapprove of Mr. Bush’s handling of the war. The survey of 1,489 adults nationwide was taken December 8 through December 11 and has a margin of sampling error of 3%.

The administration has been unwilling to commit to carrying out the panel’s recommendations, calling the report just one of a number of assessments it will use in developing a new strategy.

“I’ve detected nothing but defiance from the administration on how they want to respond,” Senator Hagel, a Republican of Nebraska, said. “I think that is very irresponsible,” he said. “What the American people think and want us to do should affect policy.”

White House spokesman Gordon Johndroe said the president “has been very clear” that he has read the study group’s report and “is taking a serious look at its recommendations.”

By a 47% to 28% margin, Americans now think Democrats can do a better job of solving the country’s problems than the president can. They also think Democrats are better able to handle Iraq, although by a narrower margin of 45% to 34%.

Democratic lawmakers are far from united on Iraq, with some, such as Rep. John Murtha of Pennsylvania, pressing for an immediate withdrawal and others, such as incoming House Intelligence Committee chairman, Rep. Silvestre Reyes, saying America should add rather than cut troops.

The poll shows that the hunger for a new approach on Iraq crosses the usual lines of political division. For example, 39% of self-described conservatives and 29% of self-identified Republicans want a fixed timetable for withdrawal, a course that the Bush administration has rejected as likely only to embolden Iraqi insurgents.

“If there isn’t a timetable, there’s no encouragement for that government to be self-supportive,” said Barbara Stauffer, a 49-year-old homemaker from Spring Grove, Pa., in a follow-up interview. “They’ll just depend on us for an unlimited amount of time,” said Ms. Stauffer, a Republican. “People will keep going over there, and there will be more deaths.”

Similarly, the poll found that 48% of Republicans think America should talk directly with Iran and Syria, a course the administration has resisted.

The poll was taken several days after the Iraq Study Group report was issued, giving the survey findings more credibility than an instant poll taken immediately after the report came out.

By most measures, Americans are increasingly pessimistic about the situation in Iraq, with only 15% saying America is winning the war, down 7 points from three months ago. A majority, or 56%, continues to say the situation there was not worth going to war over.

There is one bright spot for the president: Half of all Americans still believe his policies on terrorism and national security have made the country more secure over the past six years, compared to 26% who say they’ve made the country less secure.

The poll found that Democrats continue to bask in the glow of their November election victories as the public looks more to them than Mr. Bush for leadership next year.

Democrats have an advantage over Mr. Bush on issues ranging from immigration, by 13 percentage points, and taxes, by 9 points, to lowering drug prices, by 46 points. The only issue where the president leads is national security and the war on terrorism, on which the public gives him a 5-point edge — and even that was down from a 13-point advantage in January.

Yet the public also wants both sides to work together. By the same 2-to-1 margin, Americans expect both the president and Democrats to make compromises.

“I’m just sick of the bickering between the two parties,” said Steve Miller, a 58-year-old disabled construction worker and self-identified Republican who lives in Uvalda, Ga.

Democrats agree. “Nothing’s been done in the last four years,” said Joe McFadden, 75, a retired health-care administrator who lives in Brooklyn Center, Minn. “I expect them to compromise.”

The public is about evenly divided over whether Congress and the president will heed the call for an end to partisan squabbling, with 48% predicting Republicans and Democrats will work together and 46% forecasting gridlock.

While 57% said they don’t expect Mr. Bush to be able to accomplish much in his remaining two years in office, 67% said they think the Democrats will be able to achieve at least some of their goals.

The public’s second-highest priority for Congress, after arranging for troop drawdowns in Iraq, is to work on providing universal health care coverage in America.

Increasing the minimum wage also has strong support, with 77% of all respondents saying Congress should act on it, including 61% of Republicans.

Repeal of tax cuts for the wealthy and investors also is popular, according to the poll, with 56% of respondents favoring elimination of tax breaks for the highest-income earners. Americans are about evenly split over whether Congress should pass legislation to create a guest-worker program with a path to citizenship for foreign workers.

The poll showed deep gender divisions on some issues, including Iraq. Fifty-eight percent of women supported setting a timetable for withdrawing troops, while 46% of men did so. Men were also more likely to be optimistic about the direction of the country, with 33% saying it was on the right track, compared to 25% of females.

While the public looks to Democrats for leadership on the issues, most Americans still aren’t familiar with the party’s congressional leadership.

Half of those polled said they haven’t heard enough about the incoming House speaker, Rep. Nancy Pelosi, to have an impression, and 65% said the same about Senator Reid, who will be the Senate majority leader in January.

Twenty-seven percent had a favorable opinion of Ms. Pelosi and 21% an unfavorable one. For Mr. Reid, 21% were favorable and 12% unfavorable.

Mr. Bush’s job approval rating was 42%, a 3-point decline from September.

A majority, 62%, continues to say the nation is on the wrong track, a perception influenced by pessimism about Iraq. That number is similar to the September poll.


The New York Sun

© 2024 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  create a free account

By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use