Sharif Appeals Deportation

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

ISLAMABAD – Lawyers for former Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif filed a petition in the Supreme Court today challenging his expulsion to Saudi Arabia, setting up another confrontation between the judiciary and Pakistan’s military ruler as he battles to hold onto power.

President General Musharraf sent Mr. Sharif, the premier he ousted in a 1999 coup, back into exile yesterday hours after the opposition leader landed on a flight from London. Mr. Sharif, who had intended to return home to lead a campaign against General Musharraf, was also charged with corruption during his four-hour stay in the country.

Mr. Sharif’s lawyers yesterday petitioned the Supreme Court to start proceedings against the government for contempt in relation to the deportation. Last month, the court ruled that Mr. Sharif had an inalienable right to return home.

“We will fight this battle in the court of law,” Mr. Sharif’s nephew, Hamza Sharif, told reporters on the steps of the Supreme Court after the petition was filed. “We are fully confident that we will win, God willing.”

The Supreme Court has emerged as a check on General Musharraf’s dominance since his failed attempt to sack the country’s top judge earlier this year that sparked a nationwide protest movement.

It is already hearing petitions challenging General Musharraf’s holding of the post of army chief and president simultaneously and his eligibility to contest upcoming presidential elections. It is also pressing the government to provide information about the fate of hundreds of people allegedly held by Pakistan’s shadowy intelligence agencies on accusations of terrorism and anti-government activities.

Analysts say yesterday’s decision to expel Mr. Sharif will deepen General Musharraf’s unpopularity in Pakistan and reinforce impressions that he is an authoritarian leader. It also could undermine the legitimacy of legislative elections due by January 2008.

A senior member of the Pakistan Bar Council, Ali Ahmed Kurd, said lawyers across the country were boycotting court proceedings to protest Mr. Sharif’s deportation.

“The government intentionally and willfully violated the August23 ruling of the Supreme Court,” he said. “The government wants to curb the independence of the court that it achieved through the lawyers’ movement … We should back the independence of the judiciary.”

Deputy Information Minister Tariq Azim told the British Broadcasting Corp. yesterday that General Musharraf’s government obeyed the Supreme Court ruling to let Sharif enter the country, but that the former premier chose to go back into exile to avoid facing trial.

Mr. Sharif was originally exiled in 2000 following the coup. Accused of denying landing rights to a plane carrying General Musharraf that was short on fuel, Mr. Sharif was jailed but later released and sent to Saudi Arabia after allegedly pledging not to return for a decade.

“It was a choice given to him that either he goes to a detention center and be detained and tried, or he goes and completes his 10-year (exile) agreement that he has signed with the Saudi government,” Mr. Azim told the BBC.

“No hindrance or obstacle was placed upon his entry into Pakistan,” Mr. Azim said.

Sadiq ul-Farooq of Sharif’s Pakistan Muslim League-N party called the government’s claim that Mr. Sharif chose to go back into exile a “baseless concoction” and that he had volunteered to be arrested by police at Islamabad airport after he was served a warrant.

“He (Sharif) said, ‘If you have any cases against me, arrest me and send me to jail.’ He offered his wrists to them,” Mr. ul-Farooq said.

He estimated that more than 5,000 Sharif party workers and leaders have been arrested nationwide in recent days, including the party’s chairman and former Pakistan President Rafiq Tarar. Authorities have confirmed that hundreds were rounded up ahead of Mr. Sharif’s return.

His deportation also drew immediate criticism from the European Union, which noting the Supreme Court ruling denying authorities the right to block the return of Mr. Sharif, who was twice elected prime minister in the 1990s.

State Department spokesman Sean McCormack said the deportation “runs contrary to the Supreme Court decision,” but would not comment further because the matter was “still under legal consideration.”


The New York Sun

© 2024 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  create a free account

By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use