Lou Dobbs Makes Nightly Piñata of Spitzer

Lou Dobbs is sorry about calling Governor Spitzer an idiot.Sincerely.As for ripping the New York Democrat as arrogant, spineless and “a spoiled rich kid brat,” the host of CNN’s “Lou Dobbs Tonight” stands by those nationally broadcast broadsides.Absolutely.Mr. Dobbs has made Mr. Spitzer an almost daily target over his recent plan to ease restrictions on illegal immigrants seeking New York state driver’s licenses, mixing vitriol with sarcasm while endlessly lambasting the governor’s decision.The lifelong Republican has taken on politicians of every stripe, as when he blasted the Bush administration over port security. But his nightly diatribe against Mr. Spitzer is notable for its intensity, and for elevating a state proposal onto the national stage.“What he’s doing is an outrageous, arrogant abuse of power,” Mr. Dobbs said in an interview before a recent show. “He’s pandering to a constituency aligned directly against the interests of U.S. and New York state citizens.”Mr. Dobbs’s ire boiled over Tuesday night when he ripped Mr. Spitzer as an idiot — and then offered an on-air mea culpa.“I’m the idiot,” Mr. Dobbs said. “Governor, I apologize for calling you one. Your policies are idiotic. But I have to apologize for calling you an idiot.”Mr. Dobbs shouldn’t hold his breath waiting for a bouquet of roses (the state flower) and a thank-you note from Mr. Spitzer.“Mr. Dobbs has clearly demonstrated that he is not interested in a real debate on New York’s driver’s license policy change,” a Spitzer spokeswoman, Jennifer Givner, said. “He has repeatedly refused to offer balanced coverage of the issue.”Mr. Dobbs has turned the first-term governor into a verbal pinata over his September announcement that illegal immigrants with valid foreign passports could obtain a driver’s license.Mr. Spitzer has said the plan, set to go into effect this December, would make New York safer by bringing its 1 million illegal immigrants “out of the shadows.”Yesterday, Mr. Spitzer cut a deal with the Bush administration that would still allow the state to issue licenses to illegal immigrants — although the agreement required that their licenses would be clearly marked to indicate they are not valid federal ID.While advocates on either side of the flap said Mr. Spitzer had backed down, Homeland Security Secretary Chertoff was still upset by the state’s decision to license illegal immigrants.The Spitzer decision reversed a 2002 order by former Governor Pataki issued after the 9/11 attacks, and placed Mr. Spitzer directly in Mr. Dobbs’s cable crosshairs. But Mr. Dobbs, while perhaps the highest-profile critics of the plan, is not alone: a state poll showed 72% of New Yorkers opposed Mr. Spitzer on this issue, and Mayor Bloomberg has also expressed skepticism.Mr. Spitzer, in a speech last week, noted that “despite the hysteria this policy has created in some circles, it is simply a return to the policy we had for most of our state’s history.”Mr. Dobbs is hardly swayed by the history lesson, complaining the relaxed license requirement could produce voter fraud and raise security issues. Mr. Spitzer has ignored repeated invitations to appear on the program, Mr. Dobbs said; the show has turned down guests supporting Mr. Spitzer, including a former national counterterrorism adviser, Richard Clarke, according to Ms. Givner.Mr. Dobbs, who has made immigration one of his show’s centerpiece issues, was criticized this week in a New York Times editorial for his Spitzer bashing.“Mr. Dobbs has trained his biggest guns on Mr. Spitzer, branding him with puerile epithets like ‘spoiled rich-kid brat’ and depicting his policy as some sort of sanctuary program for the 9/11 hijackers,” the Times wrote. “Someday there may be a calm debate, in Albany and nationally, about immigrant drivers.“With Mr. Dobbs at the megaphone, for now there is only histrionics and outrage.”Mr. Dobbs isn’t expecting any apology from the Times. And he has few kind words for the newspaper.“The New York Times is the house organ for Governor Spitzer,” Mr. Dobbs said. “They’re wrong on this issue, as they are on many others.”Mr. Dobbs draws a nightly audience of roughly 800,000, making him second in CNN viewers to Larry King’s nightly program. He has no intention of lightening up on Mr. Spitzer.“Why should I?” Mr. Dobbs asked. “He’s wrong. This issue is of vital importance to the state of New York and the nation. My job as an advocacy journalist is to confront directly abuses of power and wrongheaded politics.”And sure enough, 24 hours after his “idiot” apology, Mr. Dobbs was again taking shots at Mr. Spitzer.“This governor is irresponsible,” Mr. Dobbs told his audience. “It’s clear arrogance. … He has declared himself to be what people hoped he would not be — and that is an arrogant tool of special interests.”

Lou Dobbs Makes Nightly Piñata of Spitzer

Lou Dobbs Makes Nightly Piñata of Spitzer

More from the New York Sun

Iran is Using Houthis to Unleash ‘Hell’ in Mideast — Yet Sparing Israel

Ben Shelton Leads a Home-Grown Revival That Outshines the U.S. Open’s Spectacle

Israel Strikes Back at ‘NAZA,’ Calls Film Festival Darling ‘Act of Treason Against the State’

The Economist on the ‘Reality of Islam in Europe’

McConnell Expected To Return This Week After 94-Day Absence: Report

Democrats Renew Demand for Investigations Into Trump Sons After Russian Oligarch Hosts Don Jr.’s Wedding Events

Bannon, Sanders Find Common Ground on AI as Technology Crosses Political Alliances

Rapper Macklemore Says He Was Kicked Off Ed Sheeran’s Tour After Robert Kraft ‘Rallied’ Stadium Owners

More from the New York Sun

Iran is Using Houthis to Unleash ‘Hell’ in Mideast — Yet Sparing Israel

Ben Shelton Leads a Home-Grown Revival That Outshines the U.S. Open’s Spectacle

Israel Strikes Back at ‘NAZA,’ Calls Film Festival Darling ‘Act of Treason Against the State’

The Economist on the ‘Reality of Islam in Europe’

McConnell Expected To Return This Week After 94-Day Absence: Report

Democrats Renew Demand for Investigations Into Trump Sons After Russian Oligarch Hosts Don Jr.’s Wedding Events

Bannon, Sanders Find Common Ground on AI as Technology Crosses Political Alliances

Rapper Macklemore Says He Was Kicked Off Ed Sheeran’s Tour After Robert Kraft ‘Rallied’ Stadium Owners