Nirvana In the Rose Room

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

Fashion Week starts Friday. The tents are already up in Bryant Park. Call a designer and he won’t call you back — too busy making sure his models are eating enough so as not to perpetuate an unrealistic and even unhealthy ideal of beauty. (“Tic-Tacs for everyone!”)

Even as the entire garment world is frantically sewing, sweating, hammering, and clamoring to unveil a look that will be as passé as a pancho by Christmas, however, things are moving at a very different pace just three flights up.

“I’ve been working on my book for five years,” Jonathan Gill said as he pored over a century-old volume of Harlem Life in the Rose Main Reading Room of the New York Public Library.

Mr. Gill is writing a book about the history of Harlem. Actually, he’s already written it. “It was three times too long,” he said.

So why is he doing even more research?

“Don’t put that in! If my editor sees that he’ll go crazy!” Mr. Gill said, eliciting a nasty stare from a woman trying to concentrate at the next table. “You’ll notice,” he continued, sotto voce, “I have no note-taking materials with me.” He’s just reading every single issue of the long-dead magazine because … that’s what scholars do. They research. Then they research some more. Once they end up in the Main Reading Room, they have reached research nirvana.

Take Senta Driver. She’s been researching her family history for 10 years. What makes the subject so fascinating?

“Remarkably little,” Ms. Driver said. “They saw everything happening in the history of America — all the major events — but they didn’t fight, they didn’t get into politics.”

That might be enough to dampen some folks’ genealogical enthusiasm, but Ms. Driver arrived at the Reading Room yesterday with a 1701 receipt for her great-great-great-great-somebody’s coat. She was dying to find out what kind of material it might have been made of. That’s a research junkie for you.

The junkies here even have an enabler: David Smith, a librarian ready to help just about anybody with just about any question.

“Somebody asked how to make a bullwhip,” Mr. Smith said. “I pointed him in the right direction.” Another inquirer wondered, “Were horseflies used in the cockpits of fighter planes as an indicator of air pressure?”

After great study, Mr. Smith determined: Uh, no. And then there was the guy, Mr. Smith said, “who was doing years of research to prove that a black Jewish woman named Ameilia Bassano Lanyer wrote some of Shakespeare’s plays.”

Okaaaay.

Another Shakespeare scholar was hard at work in the Reading Room yesterday. He’s writing a play about the person he thinks wrote Shakespeare’s plays (neither black nor Jewish nor female). “I’m in touch with the Royal Shakespeare Company,” the man, who would only give his name as Charles, said. “I’d like them to produce it first and then move it to Broadway.”

Let’s hope it happens soon. Charles is 85 — a former accountant. Like just about everyone else in the Reading Room (except Gill, of course), he was taking notes and having the time of his life.

L.J. Davis was working on his history of the assembly line. He’s written three books in the Reading Room, even though he meant to write only one. Mabel Gonzalez was researching the Spanish Inquisition — the one in Peru in the 1700s. Lyda Abonte de Zacklin had come in to track down a book by her favorite philosopher.

“It has to do with how our identity is getting lost and everybody is just a number,” she said. “But just at that moment when you think there is nothing, you feel desperation. And that moment saves you.”

Saved by desperation. That sounds more like the fashion world. Up in the Rose Main Reading Room, the people don’t need saving. They’re already in heaven.


The New York Sun

© 2025 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  create a free account

or
By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use