Humble Heroes

This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

The New York Sun

Baseball isn’t merely about baseball, but also, of course, about the rest of your life. We all have our own particular thoughts about its meaning. My own thoughts in this pre-baseball week have gone to Branch Rickey, a baseball man, through and through. During more than a half-century in the game, he brought remarkable players and World Series championships to three great cities, St. Louis, Brooklyn, and Pittsburgh.

Most notably, perhaps, Rickey brought dignity and integrity to the game, when, 60 years ago this April 15, he ignored unanimous opposition by the other 15 major league team owners and signed a black player, Jackie Robinson, to play for the Brooklyn Dodgers.

Thus, Rickey’s story is not just about baseball. It is a story of vision, courage, and service. Other people may associate Rickey with Robinson alone. But in this instance I have an additional thought. To me, in part because I often address civil liberties and their roots, Rickey seems not unlike England’s great abolitionist, William Wilberforce.

To begin with, there is their persistence. Wilberforce introduced a bill in the House of Commons to abolish slavery in 1791. He did so each year, until, in 1807, his bill passed. He did not then tire or tarry. He labored yet another quarter-century to aid the slaves he helped free.

Wilberforce’s lifelong aid for slaves took root following an epiphany he had in 1785. Branch Rickey had his own epiphany in 1903 when he, as a 22-year-old head coach, took his Ohio Wesleyan University baseball team to play the University of Notre Dame. When they arrived at South Bend’s old Oliver Hotel, the desk clerk said, asserts the Reverend Bob Olmstead, a Methodist minister in Palo Alto, “I have rooms for all of you — except for him” — the clerk pointed to the team’s catcher, Charles Thomas, who was black.

“Why don’t you have a room for him?” Rickey asked.

“Because our policy is whites only.”

Rickey responded, “I’d like to have Charley stay in my room. Can you bring in a cot?”

After long deliberations, the innkeeper relented. Rickey sent the ballplayers to their rooms. But when he got to his room, Charley Thomas was sitting on a chair sobbing. Rickey recounted later that Charley was pulling frantically at his hands. Charley looked at Rickey and said, “It’s my skin. If I could just tear it off, I’d be like everybody else. It’s my skin, it’s my skin, Mr. Rickey!”

Years later, those hands were the healing hands of a highly successful dentist. He never forgot his coach and Branch Rickey never forgot that experience.

As did Wilberforce’s 1785 Christian awakening, Rickey’s 1903 awakening drove him for the remainder of his life. The evils the two men despised and disputed were two sides of the same coin. Wilberforce confronted slavery, while Rickey challenged its bitter residue, “Jim Crow” laws.

In 1944, after becoming president of the Dodgers, Rickey told a friend, “For 41 years, I have heard that young man [Charles Thomas] crying. Now, I am going to do something about it. … I am going to bring a Negro to the Brooklyn Dodgers.”

Three years later, he did. Literally, Rickey filled the hollow notes in the Declaration of Independence and the Gettysburg Address — “All men are created equal” — and gave them resilience and resonance for millions of baseball fans everywhere in the nation, black and white, North and South.

Thus, Branch Rickey, a white lawyer, and Jackie Robinson, a black athlete, peacefully — without government incentive or intervention — challenged and changed baseball and the nation, seven years before the Supreme Court rendered Brown v. Board of Education, 16 years before Martin Luther King Jr. gave his memorable speech, “I Have A Dream,” at the Lincoln Memorial, and 17 years before Congress passed and the President signed the Civil Rights Act.

The former head of the American Civil Liberties Union for a quarter-century, Ira Glasser, notes, “But before all that happened … a quiet drama was beginning in a small office in Brooklyn, New York, a drama that one observer later would call ‘perhaps the most visible single desegregation action ever taken.'”

Now, on the 60th anniversary of that quiet drama, we must remember Rickey — and Wilberforce too. We must remember Robinson as well. Each man played a key role in our shared and continuing pursuit of liberty for all. Free people must never forget such men because they inspire us with their humility, grace, and courage. They help us to reach beyond ourselves.

Such heroes are gone from too many of our colleges and universities, but they endure, in our hearts and in our souls.

Our clergy still remind us occasionally of such men as did Ralph Sockman of New York in his 1965 eulogy of Rickey. Mr. Sockman reminded baseball and America, “Branch Rickey has been called the master mind of baseball. His vision made him that. But, he was also the master heart of baseball. … [H]e made goodness attractive to others.” Isn’t that true of all heroes? Isn’t that what we must teach our children again?

Mr. Nicholson is associate justice, Court of Appeal, 3rd Appellate District, State of California, and adjunct research fellow of the Independent Institute’s Center on Law and Justice in Oakland, Calif.


The New York Sun

© 2025 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.

The New York Sun

Sign in or  create a free account

or
By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use