Political Dynamite in Census Estimates Suggests Trouble Ahead for Democrats

About a month late, presumably due to last fall’s government shutdown, the Census Bureau has released its estimates of the populations of the 50 states and the District of Columbia for July 1, 2025.It provides an interesting picture of what the country is, and is becoming, halfway through the decade of the 2020s and one-quarter of the way through (have we really gotten this far?) the 21st century. It also provides some political dynamite, all the more explosive because of Census Bureau statisticians’ deserved reputation for apolitical rigor and willingness to admit mistakes, as it did on the Covid-19-plagued 2020 Census.The headline story is the sharp rise and sharp fall in immigration. The notion that immigration exploded sharply during the Biden administration and contracted sharply during the second Trump administration is not political propaganda.After the expiration of most Covid-19 restrictions, immigration rose to 1.8 million in 2021-2022, 2.6 million in 2022-2023, and 3.2 million in 2023-2024.The snapback to 1.9 million in 2024-2025 reflects changes in both outgoing and incoming administrations. With the election looming, the Biden administration in early 2024 discovered that current legislation let it restrict immigration in ways it had claimed it didn’t before. Under the same legislation, the Trump administration immediately stopped almost all illegal border crossings. Government policy can make a difference.Taking that into account, the Census Bureau estimates immigration will fall to less than 500,000 in 2025-2026. That’s comparable to the sharp falloff of immigration during the financial and economic crises of 2007-2008.That means the nation’s total population increase is sharply down, especially in the states centered on the nation’s four largest metropolitan areas, which either grew just barely (New York and Illinois), or lost population (California). Meanwhile, every state in the Midwest gained population, and five states grew above the national rate.Even more striking, 44 percent of the nation’s population gains in 2020-2025 came in just the two states of Texas and Florida. When you add in North Carolina, Georgia, Arizona, South Carolina — with the nation’s higher percentage growth in 2024-2025 — and Tennessee, you have 70 percent of the total national popular gain, all in states carried by President Trump in 2024.Projecting 2020-25 or 2024-25 patterns ahead of the 2030 Census and the reapportionment of United States House seats among the states that automatically follows results in a sharp change of political balance. Two different projections have California losing four House seats and Texas gaining four, leaving California with 48, only marginally larger than Texas’s 42.One has Florida gaining four and New York and Illinois losing two each, while the other has Florida gaining two and New York and Florida losing one each, with the same net partisan effect. There is agreement that five more or less Republican states will gain one seat each (Georgia, North Carolina, Arizona, Utah, Idaho) and that five more or less Democratic states will lose one each — Rhode Island, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Oregon.Apply either set of projections to the 2024 presidential election totals, and Trump gains either nine or 11 electoral votes — and wins even if he loses his three closest states, Wisconsin, Michigan and Pennsylvania. The blue wall has become a purple flowerbed.That doesn’t mean Democrats will be frozen out of the White House. Changes in opinion of a magnitude often experienced can render the 2024 numbers obsolete. Yet one can see difficulties, even in 2028, if Democrats nominate one of the two California politicians, Gavin Newsom or Kamala Harris, who top their polls. Will the nation be well served by policies that have prompted more people to leave than to head to a state with California’s beautiful scenery and comfortable climate?It’s harder to be sure whether the 2030 Census will give Republicans a boost in Congress. The current ructions over mid-decade redistricting make prediction perilous. An intermediate court has blocked Virginia Democrats from gerrymandering, and a trial judge has ruled that the Voting Rights Act requires linking a Staten Island-dominated district to Manhattan rather than Brooklyn.Yet almost certainly any political redistricting would rather be a Republican adding multiple districts in Texas and Florida than a Democrat required to eliminate some of his party’s incumbents in California, New York or Illinois. And heavily Democratic central cities will no longer be entitled to as much representation from masses of illegal immigrants protected from deportation but counted by census takers.A final caveat. Issues aren’t static, politicians aren’t around forever (even if Trump Derangement Syndrome sufferers fear that), and voters move around amid changes in the political landscape. The Trump era has been full of surprises — who thought he’d win in 2024 because of increased Latino support? — and the 2030s, when Trump won’t be president nor be running for president, will have its surprises for us too.Creators.com

Political Dynamite in Census Estimates Suggests Trouble Ahead for Democrats

More from the New York Sun

Jesse Tyler Ferguson Zings ‘Tru’ as Capote in a Poignant Revival

To Jay Powell: In the Name of God, Go

Clip Farming Their Way Through the ‘Manosphere’: Going Viral for Being Vile

More from the New York Sun

Jesse Tyler Ferguson Zings ‘Tru’ as Capote in a Poignant Revival

To Jay Powell: In the Name of God, Go

Clip Farming Their Way Through the ‘Manosphere’: Going Viral for Being Vile

Will Iranian Attacks Against Gulf States Reshape Regional Alliances?

Reports That Joe Kent Was Under FBI Probe May Provide New Motive for His Surprise Resignation

Sarah Huckabee Sanders Says She Was Booted From Arkansas Restaurant in Déjà Vu Moment

The Next Fight in the Iran War

‘She Got Money’: Harvey Weinstein’s Defense Quarrels With Prosecutors on His 74th Birthday Over How To Explain $500,000 Award to Accuser