A Voice That Stands Alone

Richard Wilbur has been one of America’s most tireless, successful, and recognizable poets since the end of World War II. He has remained consistent in both his conventional idea of the poet’s role in the republic of letters and his adherence to formal poetic practice and a muted style. The “Collected Poems” of his inevitable foil – and one of his closest contemporaries – Robert Lowell, was published just last year. Now it is Mr. Wilbur’s turn (Harcourt, 585 pages, $35).Mr. Wilbur’s poetry is almost implausibly serene and steady, and this equilibrium is his greatest strength. Mr. Wilbur is the hedgehog to Lowell’s fox. In a time of ruthlessly, and thoughtlessly, scattered free verse and countless bland choruses of self-regard, Mr. Wilbur’s poems seem to hail from another age altogether.He began his career fully in step with his time and generation. They believed in an untrammeled tradition of elegant lyric poetry, in the natural world as a source of spiritual wisdom, and in keeping most of the rage and raw bits behind the measured gates of their quiet poetics. By the early 1960s, however, Mr. Wilbur was falling out of step with the march of poetic progress and by 1970 he was almost peerless. The stairs of Parnassus have grown crowded with young tourists, smoking and strumming guitars; he remains in the nave, quietly meditating alone.Mr. Wilbur’s own thoughts on the harsh, self-involved confessional mode that dominates American poetry can be found in his poem “Flippancies”: “If fictive music fails your lyre, confess – / Though not, of course, to any happiness.” In a 1995 interview, he observed that it leads to “self-dramatization and celebrity posturing, neither of which make good poems.”The greater share of Mr. Wilbur’s poems are given over to themes of nature: the changing course of the seasons, the details of flora and fauna. In this he owes debts to his experiences growing up on a New Jersey farm but also to Robert Frost, whom he met while studying at Harvard. I can also sense the gravitational effects on Mr. Wilbur of Spenser’s 16th-century “Shepheard’s Calendar” and Thomas Gray’s “Elegy Written in a Country Churchyard.” Cities and towns seem hardly to exist in Mr. Wilbur’s world. When they do, they are squares of light in the distance.There is a tendency while celebrating Mr. Wilbur’s landscapes to neglect their devotional sensibility. Most poems published in English before the 19th century were in one way or another devotional – even metaphysical poetry is functionally devotional – but the type is almost entirely absent from serious contemporary American poetry. In Mr. Wilbur the natural world, as Dana Gioia put it, “becomes a sacramental means of revealing the divine order.”Mr. Wilbur’s earlier poems are colored by hues of inherited poetic diction, proceeding more from Hardy and even Longfellow than from Eliot or Pound. Despite some slightly archaic notes, they are remarkably accomplished and are distinctively similar in tone to the poems he has written right through to the present.“Mined Country,” from his first book, 1947’s “The Beautiful Changes,” is the triumph of his early career, addressing the lasting effects of war through the invisible image of the as-yet-undiscovered land mine:It’s going to be long beforeTheir war’s gone for good.I tell you it hits at childhood more than churchesFull up with sky or buried town fountains,Rooms laid open or anythingCut stone or cut wood,Seeing the boys come swinging slow over the grass(Like playing pendulum) their silver plates,Stepping with care and listeningHard for hid metal’s cry.A Wilbur poem is insightful and enjoyable, humorous and touching. He avoids any grand historical or hysterical private adventures in his poems, knowing that the lyric poem was never intended to bear such weight.Even before the rise of poetry manuals like the Norton, Wilbur had already scored a few hits on the big board of larger cultural recognition. Three stand out in particular. “Junk” from “Advice for a Prophet,” which won the Pulitzer Prize in 1961, makes use of the alliterative Anglo-Saxon style of “Beowulf” and “Piers Plowman.” (It has an Anglo-Saxon fragment as epigraph and adopts the medial or mid-line caesura common to the first English-language poetry.) The poem is a call for an enduring work ethic and a consequent desire for perfection, as opposed to the unfinished, the haphazard:Haul them off! Hide them!The heart wincesFor junk and gimcrack, for Jerry built thingsAnd the men who make them.This is all the more defiant given the poet’s admission that eventually everything will be “buried” in the “making dark” where all “work / is worn away.”“Advice for a Prophet,” essentially a nature poem outfitted for the Age of Anxiety, takes on the unthinkable – a nuclear war – by suggesting what would happen not to humans but to the rest of the world: “Nor shall you scare us with talk of the death of the race. / How should we dream of this place without us?”“Collected Poems” – which supplants the Pulitzer Prize-winning “New and Collected Poems” of 1989 – is arranged in a very confident manner, with the most recent poems placed at the beginning and the earliest at the end. Happily, Mr. Wilbur has included many of his fine translations and even made provisions for his excellent children’s poems and song lyrics.Translation is a central duty of the poet to Mr. Wilbur, and he is one of our most accomplished. Aside from W.S. Merwin, it is difficult to think of another living American poet who has undertaken such an ambitious array of translations. His stable includes Voltaire, Villon, Valery, Baudelaire, Mallarme, Apollinaire, Borges, Akhmatova, Brodsky, and Dante. He displays incredible technical facility in maintaining the original poetic forms of sonnets, rondeaus, and ballades. Portions of his dramatic translations of Racine and Moliere are included in “Collected Poems.”Mr. Wilbur has not allowed himself to be washed forward by the sea changes that have swept over postwar America. He is a constant reminder of what poetry once was and can still be. With a small coterie of others, he helped to balance the keel of American poetry when it heeled precipitously in the hard rains that have fallen since 1965. No bookshelf of American poetry can be complete without his “Collected Poems.”That said, I hope Mr. Wilbur will be remembered as much for his playful pentameters and wry humor as transcendental naturalism. These properties are most visible in his books “for children and others,” accompanied by his own simple but charming illustrations. (He has also written song lyrics and libretti; the lyric “Glitter and Be Gay” has come to be a standard of American musical theater.) Though whimsical, they are sophisticated in a way that reminds me of no one so much as Ogden Nash.The opposite of a doughnut? WaitA minute while I meditate.This isn’t easy. Ah, I’ve found it!A cookie with a hole around it.Mr. Hilbert last wrote for these pages on books about reading.

A Voice That Stands Alone

More from the New York Sun

Let Some Oil Tankers Sail Through the Strait of Hormuz — World Oil Prices Will Retreat Big Time

‘What Is Chabad Exactly?’

On Taxes in New York, It’s Mamdani v. Hochul

‘Hoppers’ is the Best Pixar Film of the Decade

Florida Senate Advances Bill To Let State Leaders Designate Groups as Terrorists After Federal Judge Blocks Effort by DeSantis

One Week In, Will Trump and Netanyahu Have Time To Finish Reshaping the Mideast and the World?

State Department Says Charter Flights Are Evacuating Hundreds of Americans Stranded in Middle East

Mayor Mamdani’s Wife Liked Posts Cheering on Hamas’s October 7 Massacre: Report