Understanding Alcoholism
This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.
People used to debate whether alcoholism was a disease or a moral failing. Now research demonstrates that it is a disease, and one with a strong genetic component.
At least 50% of the vulnerability to alcoholism is now believed to be triggered by genetics, and the other 50% by environment, such as living in a culture where heavy drinking is endemic.
It has also become increasingly clear that many genes play a role in alcoholism and that genes can work both ways – with some protecting people against alcoholism and others greatly raising the risk, said Dr. Mary-Anne Enoch, a research physician at the National Institute of Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism.
Certain groups of people, such as many Japanese, Chinese, and Jews, carry genes that protect against alcoholism by raising levels of particular liver enzymes so that it’s unpleasant to keep drinking because of nausea, flushing, and rapid heart beat.
Others, including many Caucasians, carry genes that act in the brain rather than the liver and raise the risk of becoming an alcoholic, although if people with these genes never touch a drop, they will never become alcoholics. Overall, those with a parent or sibling who is alcoholic are at three to four times the normal risk.
Even with no genetic predisposition, people can become alcoholic by constant exposure to alcohol, which turns on genes in brain cells “that set up a vicious cycle of wanting or needing more and more alcohol,” said Bill Carlezon, director of the Behavioral Genetics Laboratory at McLean Hospital in Belmont, Mass.
The goal of this genetics research is to better understand alcoholism in order to design better drugs to protect people from it.
The latest government statistics, released in August, show that alcohol problems are on the rise. An estimated 17.6 million American adults – 8.5% of the population – now fit the diagnostic criteria for having an alcohol use disorder. Definitions vary, but alcohol abuse is often defined as recurrent drinking that disrupts work, school, or home life and/or occurs in hazardous situations; alcohol dependence, also known as alcoholism, is defined as impaired control over drinking, preoccupation with drinking, withdrawal symptoms, and/or high tolerance to alcohol.
For several years now, researchers have suspected that heavy drinkers drink as a form of self-medication – to calm overactive circuits in the brain.
Several months ago, researchers at Indiana University School of Medicine reported findings on a study of 1,547 families that support this theory.
The researchers, led by Howard J. Edenberg, a professor of biochemistry, molecular biology, and molecular genetics, found that variations in one gene raise the risk of alcoholism. This gene acts on GABA, one of the brain’s chief inhibitory neurotransmitters whose job is to slow down – or calm – the firing of certain brain nerves. Tranquilizing drugs such as Valium and alcohol increase the ability of GABA to calm neural circuits.
People with a “high risk” variant of the GABA gene are at 40% increased risk of becoming alcohol-dependent.
According to researchers at University of California, San Diego, another GABA gene also seems to raise the risk of alcoholism, in this case by programming people to have a weak response to alcohol. These people need to drink large quantities of alcohol to get the same effect other people would get from less, said Dr. Marc Schuckit, a professor of psychiatry at the San Diego VA Hospital and UCSD medical school. This trait is common in some Native Americans and Koreans.
On the flip side, the genetic protection against alcoholism only goes so far – it can be overridden if a person persistently drinks heavily, Dr. Deborah Hasin, a professor of clinical public health at Columbia University, has shown.
Dr. Hasin studied Jews with the protective gene who had grown up in Israel and those who had emigrated to Israel from Russia, where heavy drinking is common. The Russian Jews were more likely to be alcoholics, said Dr. Hasin, showing that both genetics and environment clearly play a role.
That finding was also supported by a study by Christina Barr, a research fellow at the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse. She found that female monkeys who were separated from their mothers in childhood and had a high-risk gene were more likely to become alcoholics than monkeys with just the gene or just the unpleasant history.
The bottom line? So far, there are no genetic tests to tell if you’re predisposed to alcohol problems. But if you’re worried, talk to your doctor or drop in on an Alcoholics Anonymous meeting.
Some drugs may also help if your drinking is serious. Naltrexone can help reduce the craving for alcohol. Ondansetron can help reduce relapse in some alcoholics. Antabuse (disulfiram) helps by making people feel sick if they drink. And acamprosate (Campral), widely used in Europe but not yet available here, helps reduce alcohol craving.
Ms. Foreman is a lecturer on medicine at Harvard Medical School. Her columns are available at www.myhealthsense.com.