Government Asserts Broad Power To Detain Combatants at Guantanamo

WASHINGTON – Under detailed questioning by a federal judge, government lawyers asserted yesterday the U.S. military can hold foreigners indefinitely as enemy combatants at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, even if they aided terrorists unintentionally and never fought America.Could a “little old lady in Switzerland” who sent a check to an orphanage in Afghanistan be taken into custody if unbeknownst to her some of her donation was passed to Al Qaeda terrorists? asked U.S. District Judge Joyce Hens Green.“She could,” replied Deputy Associate Attorney General Brian Boyle. “Someone’s intention is clearly not a factor that would disable detention.” It would be up to a newly established military review panel to decide whether to believe her and release her.Mr. Boyle said the military can pick any foreigner who provides support to terrorists or might know of their plans. And the foreigners held on the U.S. naval base in Cuba “have no constitutional rights enforceable in this court,” Mr. Boyle told the judge.“That’s really shocking,” an attorney for 12 Kuwaiti detainees, Thomas B. Wilner, told reporters after Judge Green’s hearing. “People throughout the world will fear the United States is asserting the power to pick up little old ladies and men who made a mistake.”Judge Green presided over an initial skirmish in what promises to be a long battle to flesh out the meaning of the Supreme Court’s historic June 28 ruling that the Guantanamo prisoners can ask U.S. courts to see to it that they have a proceeding to challenge detention.In an effort to streamline the proceedings, Judge Green heard arguments in 12 cases involving 54 detainees. A colleague, District Judge Robert J. Leon, who declined to have his cases coordinated with the others at this stage, will hear almost identical arguments over two cases involving five other detainees today.The government has asked the judges to throw out the cases. Mr. Boyle said combatant status review tribunals (CSRTs), set up by the U.S. military since the Supreme Court decision, and a subsequent annual administrative review by the military provide “more than sufficient due process” to satisfy the high court.Mr. Wilner and other attorneys for detainees called the CSRT process inadequate. They said the panels, which consist of three military officers, have orders to presume the government’s evidence is accurate, accept statements given under torture, and don’t allow the detainee to have a lawyer or see secret evidence against him.“The world is waiting to see if American justice will work…whether these men will see their day in court,” Mr. Wilner told Judge Green. He said that 440 of the 550 detainees have been through the process and only one has been declared a noncombatant and released even though the government has charged only a few with crimes.Judge Green asked how the government defined an enemy combatant who aided terrorists or Afghanistan’s now-toppled Taliban regime.“It is not limited to individuals who carried a weapon and shot at American troops,” Mr. Boyle replied. They don’t have to be on the front lines; they can be strategic advisers, intelligence informants, or supply workers including cooks, he said.Attorneys for the detainees asked Judge Green to deny the government motion to dismiss the cases, to declare the CSRT panels invalid for lack of due process, to require the government to justify detentions in District Court under standard American court rules or in some other process overseen by the federal courts, and to order that Guantanamo conditions meet Geneva Convention standards.

Government Asserts Broad Power To Detain Combatants at Guantanamo

Government Asserts Broad Power To Detain Combatants at Guantanamo

More from the New York Sun

Ends Justify Means for Today’s Unprincipled Leftists, Who Promise To Upend the Constitutional Order

Drunk History? America Could Avoid Repeating Excesses of Covid, BLM by Heeding Lesson From Ancient Persia

Abdul El-Sayed’s Success Is Owed to Western Values and American Meritocracy That He Seeks To Abolish

Lily Rabe Brings Summer Magic to Shakespeare’s ‘Winter’s Tale’

‘An American Daughter’ Still Not Quite of Age

At Ohio Light Opera, Old Shows Become New Again

Do Jews Have a Place in New York Magazine’s ‘Habibi City’?

The Fight Ahead Over the Pied-à-Terre Tax

More from the New York Sun

Ends Justify Means for Today’s Unprincipled Leftists, Who Promise To Upend the Constitutional Order

Drunk History? America Could Avoid Repeating Excesses of Covid, BLM by Heeding Lesson From Ancient Persia

Abdul El-Sayed’s Success Is Owed to Western Values and American Meritocracy That He Seeks To Abolish

Lily Rabe Brings Summer Magic to Shakespeare’s ‘Winter’s Tale’

‘An American Daughter’ Still Not Quite of Age

At Ohio Light Opera, Old Shows Become New Again

Do Jews Have a Place in New York Magazine’s ‘Habibi City’?

The Fight Ahead Over the Pied-à-Terre Tax