Toss-Up Senate Races Double to Six as Midterms Near, Republicans Trail in Eight of Nine Battlegrounds

The number of Republican-held Senate seats rated as toss-ups has doubled since May, a new analysis shows, raising fresh concerns within the GOP about its ability to hold the upper chamber as the midterm homestretch begins.According to the Cook Political Report, six Senate seats are now rated as toss-ups — five of them Republican-held. In May, only three GOP seats held that designation. Alaska, Iowa, and Texas have since joined North Carolina, Maine, and Ohio as the most competitive races on the map. President Trump carried all six of those states in 2024 except Maine — four of them by double digits.The broader Senate landscape is equally stark for Republicans, who enjoy a small 53-47 advantage in the 119th Congress. The RealClearPolitics polling aggregate shows the GOP trailing in eight of the nine most competitive Senate races this cycle. Iowa is the lone exception, where Representative Ashley Hinson holds a narrow 1.4-point lead over Democrat Josh Turek.Republican candidates are down two points in Alaska, 7.5 points in Georgia, 2.3 points in Maine, 1.8 points in Michigan, 2.6 points in Ohio, two points in New Hampshire, eight points in North Carolina, and 1.9 points in Texas. A separate Nate Silver polling average tells a similar story, with Democrats leading in nine of 11 tracked races, although six are within the margin of error.Senate Majority Leader John Thune of South Carolina did not sugarcoat the situation when asked about the GOP’s prospects. “I worry about that, for sure,” Mr. Thune told Sioux Falls, South Dakota’s Keloland News. “I’m a realist, and I don’t ever try and sugarcoat things. I think it’s a competitive environment right now.”Still, Republicans are pointing to a few reasons for cautious optimism. An analysis by Echelon pollster Patrick Ruffini found that 3,312 polls had underestimated Republican support by an average of 3.7 points over the past four election cycles — a figure that jumped to 5.9 points during the summer months. “There’s a dramatic difference between midterm and presidential cycles. In the Trump era, Senate polls in presidential years have been biased towards Democrats, and they remained biased until the very end. Polls in midterm years ended up pretty accurate by election day but were very biased in the summer,” he wrote.Senator Susan Collins’ 2020 reelection is frequently cited: polling had her down roughly five points before she won by 8.6 points to hold on to her Maine seat.The GOP also holds a significant financial advantage, with Mr. Trump’s MAGA Inc. SuperPAC and party campaign arms reportedly sitting on as much as $800 million — significantly more than their Democratic counterparts. That spending has only just begun in earnest.The PAC on Saturday announced a $10 million television and digital ad buy in the Texas Senate race featuring Ken Paxton and James Talarico, one of the most hotly contested. The spending marked MAGA Inc.’s first major investment in a general election contest this cycle amid growing concern within the Republican Party over a seat once considered safe.The Texas attorney general and Republican nominee, Mr. Paxton, has faced a dearth in donations compared to the 37-year-old state representative, Mr. Talarico, whose strong fundraising has put the race in play.Democrats are also pressing their own advantages — Mr. Trump’s underwater approval ratings, persistently high gas prices, and party unity — while Republicans face internal divisions over the war in Iran and the Jeffrey Epstein files. A recent Gallup poll found Democrats hold their largest party identification advantage over Republicans since roughly 2008, at approximately 10 points.

Toss-Up Senate Races Double to Six as Midterms Near, Republicans Trail in Eight of Nine Battlegrounds

Toss-Up Senate Races Double to Six as Midterms Near, Republicans Trail in Eight of Nine Battlegrounds

More from the New York Sun

Fifty Years Ago, Robin Friday Became Soccer’s Ultimate Rock Star

Elizabeth Holmes Gets the Documentary Treatment

Iran Declares New ‘Prohibited Zone’ Around Strait of Hormuz as America Casts Doubt on Nuclear Deal

Belgium Condemned Israel for Killing Gaza Aid Worker — Now Israel Says He Was a Hamas Fighter

AfD Shakes Foundations of ‘Firewall’ as Trump and Musk Hail Rightist Resurgence That Could Remake Europe

Famed 335-Year-Old Anglican Church Set for Nightclub Debut at London

The Political Craft That Made Abraham Lincoln President

The New Deal’s Failure at Arthurdale Offers Expensive Example of the Limits of Federal Planning

More from the New York Sun

Fifty Years Ago, Robin Friday Became Soccer’s Ultimate Rock Star

Elizabeth Holmes Gets the Documentary Treatment

Iran Declares New ‘Prohibited Zone’ Around Strait of Hormuz as America Casts Doubt on Nuclear Deal

Belgium Condemned Israel for Killing Gaza Aid Worker — Now Israel Says He Was a Hamas Fighter

AfD Shakes Foundations of ‘Firewall’ as Trump and Musk Hail Rightist Resurgence That Could Remake Europe

Famed 335-Year-Old Anglican Church Set for Nightclub Debut at London

The Political Craft That Made Abraham Lincoln President

The New Deal’s Failure at Arthurdale Offers Expensive Example of the Limits of Federal Planning