
The Titanium Pen Makes Its Mark
By ROSS ANDERSON
|This article is from the archive of The New York Sun before the launch of its new website in 2022. The Sun has neither altered nor updated such articles but will seek to correct any errors, mis-categorizations or other problems introduced during transfer.

Published:
Updated:
Like all the members of the National Book Critics Circle, last month I was asked to participate in an online survey about the ethics of book reviewing. I dutifully pointed and clicked my way through the dozens of questions, some of which were no-brainers: Is it ever okay to review a book without reading all of it? (For the record, no.) But I couldn’t help feeling that, with newspapers around the country slashing their book coverage, ethical problems are the least of the problems facing the book world today. The Atlanta Journal-Constitution fired its long-serving, widely respected book-review editor, Teresa Weaver, actually prompting protesters to picket the building. The Los Angeles Times Book Review, one of the nation’s best stand-alone book reviews, was folded into another section of the Sunday paper. More and more regional newspapers are replacing local reviewers with wire coverage, or dropping their book reviews altogether. In this context, the NBCC survey seemed a bit like rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic.

By ROSS ANDERSON
|
By MATTHEW RICE
|
By SEBASTIAN DOGGART
|
By GARY GASTELU
|
By CARL ROLLYSON
|
By MATTHEW RICE
|
By JOSEPH CURL
|
By DAVID JONES
|Like all the members of the National Book Critics Circle, last month I was asked to participate in an online survey about the ethics of book reviewing. I dutifully pointed and clicked my way through the dozens of questions, some of which were no-brainers: Is it ever okay to review a book without reading all of it? (For the record, no.) But I couldn’t help feeling that, with newspapers around the country slashing their book coverage, ethical problems are the least of the problems facing the book world today. The Atlanta Journal-Constitution fired its long-serving, widely respected book-review editor, Teresa Weaver, actually prompting protesters to picket the building. The Los Angeles Times Book Review, one of the nation’s best stand-alone book reviews, was folded into another section of the Sunday paper. More and more regional newspapers are replacing local reviewers with wire coverage, or dropping their book reviews altogether. In this context, the NBCC survey seemed a bit like rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic.
Already have a subscription? Sign in to continue reading
Cancel anytime
By continuing you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.
Cancel anytime