Liberal Legal Establishment Fails To Keep Up With Clarence Thomas’s Transformation of American Jurisprudence

An important new book by Senator Ted Cruz, “Going Further,” calls attention anew to the life and career of the single greatest living American, Justice Clarence Thomas.For many years after Justice Thomas arrived on the court in the early 1990s, his conservative, originalist views were relegated to dissenting opinions. Three and a half decades later, Justice Thomas, now the second-longest-serving justice in the court’s history, regularly finds himself in the majority.Justice Thomas, in short, has won the long game. Yet how?Thirty-five years ago, mainstream legal training and judicial practice suggested the proper way to interpret a legal document is to probe for nebulous concepts such as legislative history and legislative intent. It’s now hard to believe, but the commonsense notion that one should begin the interpretive exercise with a document’s text and plain meaning was pretty much unheard of.Justice Thomas, along with his then-colleagues, Justice Antonin Scalia and Chief Justice Rehnquist, galvanized an intellectual revolution in American legal and judicial practice. Today, law schools instruct students to begin the interpretive exercise with the text. In fact, this is hardly controversial. As the liberal justice, Elena Kagan, put it in a 2015 Harvard Law School lecture, “We’re all textualists now.”A big part of the reason for this success is simple: sheer persuasiveness. The straightforward nature of the originalist and textualist position quickly found mass appeal, putting defenders of legislative history or “living constitutionalism” on their back feet. They haven’t been able to keep up.In the area of legal interpretation, liberals have lost the public argument — badly. In recent years, we’ve seen this manifest in conservative victories at the high court on religious liberty, abortion, gun rights, affirmative action, and the administrative state.There is an underappreciated additional ingredient in Justice Thomas’s winning formula: his kindness, affability, and genuine human decency.Justice Thomas’s life story is the stuff of legend. He grew up in the most abject poverty imaginable in Jim Crow-era rural Georgia. English was not even his first language. He overcame all that, in addition to his onetime wavering faith and even an infatuation with Malcolm X and the Black Power movement, to become one of the greatest conservatives in American history.Here’s the thing: Thomas never forgot where he came from.It is well known that, inside the Supreme Court building, Justice Thomas is the personal favorite justice. That’s true for the justices themselves, it’s true for the law clerks, and it’s even true for the janitors. Justice Thomas is the justice who will talk Nascar with the court security guard (he’s a big fan of the sport), and he is the justice who will regale law clerks with funny stories from years gone by — with his signature, boisterous laugh.The one topic Justice Thomas will not talk about, because it would offend his old-school Southern manners, is himself.The Supreme Court, unlike Congress or the executive branch, is a small, intimate institution. Passions can run high, but a justice can best achieve success over the long haul if he can persuade his colleagues in conferences, memoranda and other communications. As the saying goes, you usually catch more flies with honey than with vinegar.That was not always Scalia’s way, but it is definitely Justice Thomas’s way.The next Supreme Court term begins in just over a month, and the court’s senior-most member will once again anchor the court’s originalist bloc.There will be Viramontes v. Cook County, a prime opportunity to extend a Second Amendment guarantee to modern sporting rifles (“AR-15s”). There will be St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy, another case out of stubborn Colorado that could, and should, extend otherwise-universal preschool voucher access to religious schools. Other big cases on the docket touch on voting rights, climate change, and more.Justice Thomas’s influence will be palpable. He will once again serve the role he always has: that of dependable workhorse and beacon of intellectual clarity. He will once again be the court’s most principled originalist, establishing a barometer off of which other originalists can assess their own instincts and rulings.In a nation short on exemplary role models, Justice Thomas fills the void. He would never dream of saying so himself, but Justice Thomas is an American hero and the nation’s most inspiring man.The only question is whether he will stay on the court until May 20, 2028, at which point he will become the nation’s longest-serving justice ever.If there’s one thing we know from Justice Thomas’s life: Don’t bet against him.Creators.com

Liberal Legal Establishment Fails To Keep Up With Clarence Thomas’s Transformation of American Jurisprudence

Liberal Legal Establishment Fails To Keep Up With Clarence Thomas’s Transformation of American Jurisprudence

More from the New York Sun

The Last Patrician President: A Biography Reassesses George H.W. Bush’s Legacy

Rezvani Turns the Corvette Into a 1,560-Horsepower Fighter Jet

Outnumbered 3-to-1: The Men Who Could Sway the Lindsay Clancy Jury

House Intelligence Committee Warns a New ‘Failure of Imagination’ Could Be Setting America Up for an AI Attack

College Football Cartel Huddles With Congress To Team Up Against Players

Widow of Moonies’ Founder Sentenced to Two Years in Korea for Accepting a Chanel Handbag and Necklace as a Bribe

More Than 1,200 New Yorkers To Receive ‘Nevermind’ Pied-à-Terre Notices as City ‘Backpedals,’ More Get New ‘Nastygrams,’ Court Hears

Beyond the Luxury Box: How a New Guard of Female Owners Is Reshaping Pro Sports

More from the New York Sun

The Last Patrician President: A Biography Reassesses George H.W. Bush’s Legacy

Rezvani Turns the Corvette Into a 1,560-Horsepower Fighter Jet

Outnumbered 3-to-1: The Men Who Could Sway the Lindsay Clancy Jury

House Intelligence Committee Warns a New ‘Failure of Imagination’ Could Be Setting America Up for an AI Attack

College Football Cartel Huddles With Congress To Team Up Against Players

Widow of Moonies’ Founder Sentenced to Two Years in Korea for Accepting a Chanel Handbag and Necklace as a Bribe

More Than 1,200 New Yorkers To Receive ‘Nevermind’ Pied-à-Terre Notices as City ‘Backpedals,’ More Get New ‘Nastygrams,’ Court Hears

Beyond the Luxury Box: How a New Guard of Female Owners Is Reshaping Pro Sports