Luddites, Deploying Junk Science and Scaremongering, Are Winning the Debate on Data Centers

When Governor Kathy Hochul signed a one-year moratorium on new large-scale data centers via executive order, it became the nation’s first statewide ban.It will likely be popular. Polls find widespread opposition to data centers, and the objections seem to be growing. Around 70 percent oppose the construction of a new artificial intelligence data center in their area, with 48 percent strongly opposed. Only 27 percent favor it.Even in Texas, the energy-rich state with the most data centers, Governor Greg Abbott has called for a ban on new developments in rural areas.The panic surrounding data centers is highly reminiscent of the panic surrounding hydraulic fracturing. Like the fracking ban in New York, also based on junk science and scaremongering — not to mention, initially a “moratorium” — the policy will backfire.The economic case for data centers is indisputable. A single hyperscale facility brings in billions in capital investment, creates a slew of high-paying jobs from construction to engineering and ensures local governments are flush with tax revenue.Big Tech bogeymen such as Microsoft, Google, Amazon, and Meta upgrade local infrastructure and create secondary economies, often in struggling areas. Long term, these companies offer self-sustaining economic activity that the magical “green” industry never did or could.At Loudoun County, Virginia, home of the largest concentration of data centers in the country, studies found revenue from AI infrastructure accounted for 95 percent of the county’s operating budget. That revenue has funded a $100 million plan for new schools in the county of 455,000 residents.Because energy price spikes have coincided with the data center debate, one of the major concerns you hear from people is that their utility bills will go up. The data don’t bear this out.States with fast-growing electricity rates, such as California, have few data centers, while states such as Virginia, which lead the country in data center energy consumption, have seen electricity prices increase at the national average.There’s considerable evidence that data centers have eased electricity rate hikes over the past decade, as companies took on a growing share of the utility costs, reducing the demand on residents.AI infrastructure requires massive amounts of continuous power. Data centers are driving a rapid expansion in power generation. The solution to high energy demand isn’t to build fewer data centers. It’s to generate more energy.Trepidation over AI also surely plays a role in concern over data centers. That’s a perfectly legitimate and important debate for society to have. The most emotional and effective attacks on data centers revolve around environmental concerns.The other day, a popular WNBA player, Sophie Cunningham, asked: “So how do we save our farm land and stop all these dumb data centers?”Save farmland? Data centers are predicted to use around 1,400 square miles of land by 2028. Farmland already uses 1.4 million square miles. There’s more than enough land for farms and data centers.If anything, data centers might save farming communities. A large, self-perpetuating data center project at Farmville at rural Prince Edward County, Virginia, for instance, will optimize the land mass used by a small farm to the tune of a $5 billion investment into that community.Data centers consume somewhere around 2 percent to 4 percent of total freshwater withdrawals, a tiny fraction compared to agriculture or manufacturing, mining or basically any other major industry. Nationally, data centers consume significantly less water than golf courses.Not long ago, Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez produced two jars with brown water at a congressional hearing, alleging that it was what “drinking water” looked like at Morgan County, Georgia, where a Meta data center project was underway. Scary stuff.Except, earlier reports found only four households in the country had been stuck with sediment-clogged, brown or dry taps.Brown drinking water was not widespread, as Ms. Ocasio-Cortez had claimed. More importantly, construction projects that burst wells on occasion aren’t unique to data centers but rather to construction of all types.In a major solar project in upstate New York, crews accidentally struck an aquifer while drilling not long ago. Does Ms. Ocasio-Cortez believe we should put a moratorium on solar panel projects?Anyone who cares about the environment should also note that data centers facilitate considerable efficiencies elsewhere, such as remote work that reduces commuting emissions, better supply chain organization that cuts waste, and cloud computing that’s far more efficient than having everyone running their own servers.The effective voices against data centers, after all, are the same Luddites who’ve spread environmental apocalypticism to stop modernization projects such as pipelines and power plants and fracking. Most of their arguments don’t hold water. That doesn’t mean they’re not winning.Creators.com

Luddites, Deploying Junk Science and Scaremongering, Are Winning the Debate on Data Centers

Luddites, Deploying Junk Science and Scaremongering, Are Winning the Debate on Data Centers

More from the New York Sun

Barring Unexpected Election Day Losses, Schumer Looks Undefeatable as Returning Democratic Leader

Charges Against James Comey Hang in Balance as Judge Warns Trump Administration Against ‘Dawn Raid’ Arrest

Welcome to Washington: The Redistricting Wars Are Just Getting Started

Multiple Counties Plan To Keep DOJ Election Monitors Outside of Polling Places on Tuesday

Democratic Socialists Poised for Major Gains in Congress as ‘Squad’ Set To Expand

Fox News Has Its Weakest Month in 25 Years, Offering a Glimpse of Post-Trump Shockwave

In ‘Waiting for Lefty,’ Class Struggle Remains Unfinished Business

North Korea’s Highly Paid Cyber-Warriors Steal the Billions Needed To Finance Nuclear and Missile Programs

More from the New York Sun

Barring Unexpected Election Day Losses, Schumer Looks Undefeatable as Returning Democratic Leader

Charges Against James Comey Hang in Balance as Judge Warns Trump Administration Against ‘Dawn Raid’ Arrest

Welcome to Washington: The Redistricting Wars Are Just Getting Started

Multiple Counties Plan To Keep DOJ Election Monitors Outside of Polling Places on Tuesday

Democratic Socialists Poised for Major Gains in Congress as ‘Squad’ Set To Expand

Fox News Has Its Weakest Month in 25 Years, Offering a Glimpse of Post-Trump Shockwave

In ‘Waiting for Lefty,’ Class Struggle Remains Unfinished Business

North Korea’s Highly Paid Cyber-Warriors Steal the Billions Needed To Finance Nuclear and Missile Programs