Jack Smith Faces Legal Reckoning for One of the ‘Worst Abuses of Government Power in Our Nation’s History’

The lawsuit brought by Senator Marsha Blackburn in a federal court in Tennessee against Special Counsel Jack Smith marks a new phase in Republican efforts to hold him accountable for his prosecutions of President Trump.Ms. Blackburn’s complaint declares that the “grave abuse of authority that this case seeks to rectify began with Attorney General Merrick Garland’s lawless appointment of Jack Smith as a so-called Special Counsel.” She alleges that a subpoena that allowed the prosecutor access to her telephone metadata violated the Constitution’s protections to lawmakers.Mr. Smith sought to convict Mr. Trump for instigating the January 6, 2021, riot and for the storage of secret documents at Mar-a-Lago, but both cases were dismissed. Those subpoenas, which were accompanied by nondisclosure orders, were secured as part of Mr. Smith’s probe into Mr. Trump’s responsibility for the aftermath of January 6, codenamed “Operation Arctic Frost.” Ms. Blackburn writes that the investigation was named after “a type of orange and was chosen to mock Trump’s complexion.” The Arctic Frost Satsuma is a cold-hardy mandarin hybrid that features an intense orange.The constitutional bedrock under Ms. Blackburn’s suit is the Speech or Debate Clause, which mandates that lawmakers “shall in all Cases, except Treason, Felony and Breach of the Peace, be privileged from Arrest during their Attendance at the Session of their respective Houses, and in going to and returning from the same; and for any Speech or Debate in either House, they shall not be questioned in any other Place.” The Supreme Court held in 1972’s ruling Gravel v. United States that the protection extends to all “legislative acts.” Special Counsel Jack Smith arrives to testify during a hearing before the House Judiciary Committee on January 22, 2026, at Washington, DC. Alex Wong/Getty ImagesThe lawsuit is unusual because Speech or Debate Claims are usually adjudicated in advance. Such a contest was waged between Mr. Smith and Senator Lindsey Graham in 2022, when the special counsel sought the solon’s testimony in front of a grand jury. The issue eventually reached the Supreme Court, which shielded Mr. Graham from some questions but mandated that he answer others. Ms. Blackburn is seeking a declaration that Mr. Smith conspired to violate her rights, $1 in symbolic damages, and an order that the Justice Department destroy her records. Mr. Smith testified earlier this week that the data he collected from 14 Republican lawmakers and text messages he gathered from 44 lawmakers “added to the powerful evidence we had of Donald Trump’s guilt.” Mr. Smith claims that Mr. Trump was guilty “beyond a reasonable doubt.” Mr. Smith also testified, “We took our obligations seriously under the Speech or Debate Clause. It’s, in my view, an important part of the separation of powers. I had members of my staff who were very familiar with the clause, having worked in the public integrity section for years. We also, when it was appropriate or required, consulted with the public integrity section regarding application of that clause.”Ms. Blackburn’s suit echoes allegations levied by Congressman Jim Jordan in a report he published last week. Mr. Jordan claims that Mr. Smith “ran roughshod over key constitutional protections” and that Mr. Garland, who appointed Mr. Smith without Senate confirmation, used the “DOJ as a weapon against its political opponents” and “tried to silence President Trump.” In an even more explosive allegation, Mr. Jordan writes that Mr. Smith “admitted privately” to Mr. Garland that lawmakers “likely have a valid Speech or Debate privilege immunizing them from compelled testimony,” but that Mr. Garland still gave his “blessing” to Mr. Smith. Transcripts published last week by Senator Charles Grassley disclose that one of Mr. Smith’s deputies, Tad Dupree, testified in respect of the constitutional constraints that it is “a common thing, particularly in complex investigations, to run into the corners of the law that aren’t fully built out.”The notion that the Speech or Debate clause isn’t fully built out might perplex the Framers, given the clarity with which they ordained the point. The Constitution exempts no federal legislator. They are protected for “any” speech or debate “in either House,” and “shall not be questioned in any other Place.” There could be few stronger formulations than “any.”On the same day that Ms. Blackburn filed her lawsuit her fellow Volunteer State senator, Bill Hagerty, lodged a bar complaint against Mr. Smith alleging “serious misconduct.” Mr. Hagerty wrote on X that the special counsel is “a blatantly partisan actor and his prosecutorial misconduct damaged our constitutional order. He should never be able to practice law again.” The complaint, submitted to the Tennessee state bar, contends that Mr. Smith violated his “duty of candor” when he obtained nondisclosure orders for his subpoenas. Mr. Hagerty, who has served in the Senate since 2021, was one of the lawmakers whose telephone metadata was obtained by Mr. Smith. The senator urges the Tennessee bar to “investigate and pursue the most serious remedy possible — disbarment — in light of the gravity” of Mr. Smith’s “intentional conduct.” Mr. Smith also faces a separate criminal referral to the Department of Justice from Mr. Jordan over allegations he lied to Congress.

Jack Smith Faces Legal Reckoning for One of the ‘Worst Abuses of Government Power in Our Nation’s History’

Jack Smith Faces Legal Reckoning for One of the ‘Worst Abuses of Government Power in Our Nation’s History’

More from the New York Sun

Will Iran Try To Force a War Sooner Rather Than Later?

NYC Comptroller Mark Levine’s Broken Pledge on Israel Bonds Will Fuel BDS, Predecessor Tells the Sun

Exclusive: Selma Blair on Her Troubled Hollywood Post-October 7 Cancellation

What Would Advances by the Democrats Mean?

If Blakeman Takes Down Hochul, That Means Knocking Out Mamdani, Too

Microbiology Student Captured Trying To Flee to China After Allegedly Poisoning Colleague Over Coveted Technology Patents

Democrats Dismiss Idea El-Sayed Has a Problem With Black Voters as Rogers Hopes To Make Inroads

Mamdani Calls Blakeman a Racist After GOP Nominee for Governor Said the Mayor Was an Antisemite

More from the New York Sun

Will Iran Try To Force a War Sooner Rather Than Later?

NYC Comptroller Mark Levine’s Broken Pledge on Israel Bonds Will Fuel BDS, Predecessor Tells the Sun

Exclusive: Selma Blair on Her Troubled Hollywood Post-October 7 Cancellation

What Would Advances by the Democrats Mean?

If Blakeman Takes Down Hochul, That Means Knocking Out Mamdani, Too

Microbiology Student Captured Trying To Flee to China After Allegedly Poisoning Colleague Over Coveted Technology Patents

Democrats Dismiss Idea El-Sayed Has a Problem With Black Voters as Rogers Hopes To Make Inroads

Mamdani Calls Blakeman a Racist After GOP Nominee for Governor Said the Mayor Was an Antisemite