Socialism’s Failures Fuel French Rioting, Yet the Left Would Import the Same Policies Here

“This is what happens when nations let wealth and power accumulate in the hands of a few,” says the prospective 2028 presidential candidate and socialist, Congressman Ro Khanna about the mass rioting and social unrest unfolding in France.As with most issues, Mr. Khanna has it backward. It’s Democratic economic and social ideas that have destabilized France.France, after all, is home to socialized medicine, high minimum wages, powerful unions, some of the most generous worker protections in the world, big government spending, and a vast welfare state.France’s standard measure of income inequality, the Gini index, is just under 32, around the European Union average. To be sure, income inequality, the hobbyhorse of the American left, is completely irrelevant in and of itself. France, say, ranks in the mid-50s worldwide in income inequality, between the stable and wealthy Western democracy of Japan and the destitute Asian tyranny of Myanmar.Rioters did not set fire to the majestic 19th-century Limoges town hall because they’re angry about France’s ranking in global income parity. The riots were triggered in large part by the French government’s alleged “austerity” plans.France spends an inordinate percentage of its budget on welfare and social protection programs — a larger percentage than virtually any nation on Earth. Since 1995, social and welfare spending has risen from 53 percent to nearly 59 percent of the country’s budget. It will never be enough for rioters.Because such a significant percentage of its budget is dedicated to keeping the welfare state operational, any reforms aimed at reducing spending or debt will be greeted with immediate social turmoil.France’s public debt is approaching 120 percent of gross domestic product, and it is projected to rise to around 122 percent soon. The government recently proposed reducing the budget deficit to 5 percent in 2027 of gross domestic product from an expected 5.4 percent in 2026.In other words, young French people are destroying their cities over a proposed deficit reduction of 0.4 percentage points of GDP.To pay for this system, France has among the highest tax rates in the developed world. Employer social security contributions average around 45 percent of gross salary, while employee contributions add another 22 percent to 25 percent. The tax on consumer goods is 20 percent.That is a heavy burden for productive members of French society. Yet more than 50 percent of French households don’t pay any income tax. Despite benefiting from the system, they are untethered from the responsibilities of governing.Other nations with generous social welfare programs, such as Denmark, also have high levels of social cohesion, and virtually every household pays some income tax.“We spend too much money, and we strip people of responsibility,” President Emmanuel Macron said back in 2018. France, he adds, spends “an insane amount” on “minimal welfare payments, but people are still poor. Those born poor, stay poor. Those who become poor, stay poor. We have to do something to get people out of this situation.”France has one of the highest unemployment rates in Europe and one of the lowest retirement ages. Youth unemployment is higher than 21 percent. It’s 9 percent in the United States, and we rightly consider it a problem.Unemployment among Muslim youth is far higher. And over 34 percent of France’s young people have immigrant parents or grandparents, most from Muslim-majority countries. More than 15 percent of the population in the Paris metropolitan area is Muslim. Despite the press’s best efforts to convince us otherwise, plenty of the violence appears connected to Muslim immigrants and the nihilistic Palestinianism that Mr. Khanna champions.Riots will radicalize politics. Many French people detest anarchy, which might bode well for right-wing opposition leader Marine Le Pen in the next election. Should she succeed, that, too, will almost surely lead to more social unrest.It’s true that the French have never needed much to riot. There was major social unrest in France every year from 2005 through 2009, then in 2018 and 2019, in 2023, in 2025, and again this year. Many of those riots have been driven by reliance on the government or by Muslims living in the Paris suburbs.The more you hook people on state dependency, the less likely they are to break free of their situation. The more unassimilated people and illiberal ideas you import into your country, the less social cohesion you will get. France is the future Khanna imagines for us.Creators.com

Socialism’s Failures Fuel French Rioting, Yet the Left Would Import the Same Policies Here

Socialism’s Failures Fuel French Rioting, Yet the Left Would Import the Same Policies Here

More from the New York Sun

Mamdani Courts Voters With No-ID Pitch as GOP Sounds Alarm

El-Sayed Lagging Far Behind Democratic Candidate for Michigan Governor, Poll Shows

Fearing American ‘Kill Switches,’ European Militaries Are Buying Local

Swing Voters Grow Wary of Socialism and the Democrats’ Leftward Shift, New Polls Show

Gorsuch and Sotomayor Join Forces To Challenge Chicago’s $264 Million Car-Seizure Scheme as Unconstitutional

Welcome to Washington: How Ugly Will the Lame-Duck Be?

A Quarter of Depression Cases May Be Driven by Broken Body Clock, Study Finds

Roy Lichtenstein’s Latest New York Engagement

More from the New York Sun

Mamdani Courts Voters With No-ID Pitch as GOP Sounds Alarm

El-Sayed Lagging Far Behind Democratic Candidate for Michigan Governor, Poll Shows

Fearing American ‘Kill Switches,’ European Militaries Are Buying Local

Swing Voters Grow Wary of Socialism and the Democrats’ Leftward Shift, New Polls Show

Gorsuch and Sotomayor Join Forces To Challenge Chicago’s $264 Million Car-Seizure Scheme as Unconstitutional

Welcome to Washington: How Ugly Will the Lame-Duck Be?

A Quarter of Depression Cases May Be Driven by Broken Body Clock, Study Finds

Roy Lichtenstein’s Latest New York Engagement