Dershowitz: Trump’s Peace Plan Succeeds Because of Israel’s Military Victories

President Trump’s brilliant diplomacy has resulted in freeing the hostages and implementing a cease-fire. If the truce persists, it will be a great accomplishment and an important step toward peace — if only a cold peace — in the region. It might also provide a stepping stone to a more enduring and somewhat warmer peace. Mr. Trump deserves enormous credit for his role in putting together a coalition of Arab and Muslim states and in pressuring both sides to accept what they each understandably regard as compromises.It is important to note, though, that Israel’s decisive military victories in Gaza, Lebanon, Syria, and Iran were the essential prerequisite to Mr. Trump’s accomplishments. These victories, which were extremely costly to both sides in human lives, made it possible to pressure Hamas to accept an agreement that many Hamas supporters regard as near-suicidal to the organization.Because of Israel’s spectacular military accomplishments, Hamas lost the support of its major allies, especially Hezbollah, Syria, and Iran. It was also in the process of losing support among Palestinians, particularly in Gaza, because of the enormous toll the war, started by Hamas, exacted from civilians. Without Israel’s military successes combined with Mr. Trump’s diplomatic pressures, Hamas would still be fighting, the hostages would still be in Gaza tunnels, and there would be more bloodshed and death on both sides.Tal Kupershtein stands up from his wheelchair to hug his son Bar, a hostage released from Hamas captivity on October 13, 2025. Israeli Defense Forces via XHad Israel followed the terrible advice it was offered by the Biden administration, by the New York Times’s opinion pages including the nearly always-wrong Thomas Friedman, by American left-wing academics, by CNN pundits, and by others who counseled “restraint,” Israel would not have entered Rafah.Israel, too, would have abandoned the Philadelphi corridor; it would never have bombed Iranian nuclear facilities; it would not have aggressively gone after Hezbollah and other Iranian surrogates in the region, and it would have agreed to a cease-fire on disadvantageous terms.Even if it had followed this awful advice, the anti-Israel and antisemitic demonstrations around the world would not have diminished, because they were not designed to help Palestinians, but rather to hurt the nation-state of the Jewish people. Israel was wise to ignore the ignorant and bigoted condemnation and name calling that it has endured since October 7. It was wise to focus on the only thing its enemies in the middle east understand, and that is victory through strength.Israel’s enemies had to be convinced that the Israeli blood that was shed on October 7 was not cheap and that future attempts to shed Jewish blood — whether in the Middle East or around the world — will be responded to disproportionately. The message Israel has sent is that for every Israeli life that is taken by terrorists, multiple terrorists’ lives will be taken, even if that requires some collateral damage to non-terrorists who support or cheer-on the terrorism. An Israeli soldier heading toward Gaza in an armored personnel carrier, October 14, 2023. AP/Ariel SchalitThis justly disproportionate payback will not be deterred by these terrorists hiding behind human shields. Nor will it be deterred by fear of bigoted and one-sided condemnation of Israel by antisemites. Whatever legitimate criticisms that may have been directed at Israel overreactions were drowned out by the illegitimate condemnation of Israel for doing what every democracy would do and has done.The only response terrorists understand is making them pay a disproportionately heavy price for endangering Israeli life. Hamas leaders have threatened to repeat October 7, over and over again. Israel has counter-threatened that if they try to repeat October 7, Israel will repeat the two years that followed it, including the targeting of your leaders, wherever they are. Deterrence through disproportionately overwhelming strength is the only way the Jewish state can live in peace and safety. It is also the only way other Arab and Muslim nations will consider making real peace and joining the Abraham Accords.This reality — and its corollary that weakness produces aggression and death — has been proven over and over again through the millennia. As the Psalmist wrote: “God will give his people strength.” And then: “God will bless his people with peace.”This self-evident truth was proven once again when Mr. Trump was able to bring about peace following demonstrated overwhelming strength by Israel and America. This peace will endure only as long as this overwhelming strength endures, along with a willingness to use it when necessary.

Dershowitz: Trump’s Peace Plan Succeeds Because of Israel’s Military Victories

Dershowitz: Trump’s Peace Plan Succeeds Because of Israel’s Military Victories

More from the New York Sun

Will the Supreme Court Rescue the Trump Ballroom?

Ex-Cambridge Professor Who Resigned Amid Plagiarism Scandal Found Dead

Alleged CIA Role in Covert Sea Strikes Suggests New Facet to Trump’s South American Anti-Drug Campaign

Despite Matt Miller Scandal, Philanthropy Has Found a Home in Fantasy Football

Woke 2.0 Is Worse Than Woke 1.0

Mangione’s Death Trap: Killer Details How He Lured CEO to His Fatal Meeting

El-Sayed’s Radical Half-Sister Creates Headaches for Democrat’s Senate Campaign

Progressives Blast Mamdani for ‘Escalating’ Arrests of Black and Brown New Yorkers for Low-Level Offenses

More from the New York Sun

Will the Supreme Court Rescue the Trump Ballroom?

Ex-Cambridge Professor Who Resigned Amid Plagiarism Scandal Found Dead

Alleged CIA Role in Covert Sea Strikes Suggests New Facet to Trump’s South American Anti-Drug Campaign

Despite Matt Miller Scandal, Philanthropy Has Found a Home in Fantasy Football

Woke 2.0 Is Worse Than Woke 1.0

Mangione’s Death Trap: Killer Details How He Lured CEO to His Fatal Meeting

El-Sayed’s Radical Half-Sister Creates Headaches for Democrat’s Senate Campaign

Progressives Blast Mamdani for ‘Escalating’ Arrests of Black and Brown New Yorkers for Low-Level Offenses