Dublin Sets Planning for United Ireland in Motion on an Island Haunted by the ‘Troubles’

The Republic of Ireland’s establishment of a new government body tasked with exploring various “constitutional futures” for the island brings into sharp relief the possibility of a united Ireland, a prospect viewed with elation by some and dread by others.The announcement was teased in a speech on Wednesday by Taoiseach Micheál Martin, who expanded on the plans in an interview released on Friday. The new department will be housed under the Department of the Taoiseach. Its primary remit will be to research the legal, logistical, and cultural implications of three possible dispositions of the question of Northern Ireland, which is currently part of the United Kingdom.The first possibility that the body will examine is a unitary 32-county all-Ireland state, which has long been the dream of Irish republicans. In 1921, following the War of Independence fought with Britain, Ireland was partitioned into the 26-county Republic of Ireland and the six counties of Northern Ireland. That arrangement, though, gave way decades later to the 30-year stretch of urban warfare known as the “Troubles,” which claimed some 3,600 lives, half of them civilians.The new government organ will also study the feasibility of continuing with the status quo as well as map out a future Ireland that is technically united but in which Northern Ireland would remain a devolved entity with its own parliament and police. Ireland was first invaded in 1169 by Anglo-Norman forces fighting on behalf of the English Plantagenet king, Henry II. “The Troubles,” centered at Belfast, pitted the British Army and unionist paramilitary forces — largely Protestant — against the Provisional Irish Republican Army, a Catholic and republican organization. Decades of violence came to an end with the signing of the Good Friday Agreement in 1998. That accord left Northern Ireland under British rule, albeit with its own devolved parliament, called Stormont.A provision of the Good Friday Agreement mandates that His Majesty’s Government is required to call a referendum on Irish unity — to be decided by a simple majority vote — if it appears likely to the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland, who reports to the prime minister in London, that a majority of voters would support leaving the United Kingdom.A protestor in an Irish flag balaclava at Portadown, Northern Ireland, September 29, 2026. Charles McQuillan/Getty ImagesThe current occupant of 10 Downing Street, Prime Minister Andy Burnham, has poured cold water on any enthusiasm for a united Ireland. In August, during his first official visit to Belfast, he declared that any prospect of the kind of plebiscite envisioned by the Good Friday Agreement was “off the table” — as were secessionist aspirations in Scotland and Wales, other restive territories of the United Kingdom.A different view, though, was taken by President Trump when he touched down in Dublin in September. The 47th president contended that a united Ireland would be “fantastic” and “makes sense.” He declared at the Irish Open — played at one of his golf courses in the country — that “It just seems to me that you have Northern Ireland and you have Ireland, and it would seem to me that one of the naturals of all time is to put them together.”A reminder that the wounds of the Troubles have not entirely healed came in the standoff over a planned march by the Protestant and unionist Orange Order through the Northern Irish town of Portadown. Held on July 12, the march celebrates the Glorious Revolution and the victory of the Protestant King, William of Orange, over the Catholic king, James II, at the Battle of the Boyne. It has been the site of repeated violence.While the march has been banned for decades, last month courts allowed it to go forward. That prompted protests from Catholic republicans who saw the return of the Orange Order as a reversion to the bloody days of yore. A two-week standoff ensued, with the Garvaghy Road route blocked by protesters. Earlier this month, the secretary of state for Northern Ireland, Sir Chris Bryant, stepped in to block the march. On Wednesday, the High Court at Belfast ruled that the ban was lawful.The ruling, though, also acknowledged that “Depressingly, the threat of serious and widespread disorder has loomed large” and that “Significant concerns have now been expressed about respect for the rule of law in this jurisdiction.” Some unionists see the brouhaha over the march as a baleful harbinger of what could happen if the Protestant North, much of which sees itself as British, is absorbed into the largely Catholic Republic of Ireland.Another reminder that violence is not entirely in the rearview mirror came in July, when, as The New York Sun reported, an “extremely significant car bomb” was discovered in County Monaghan, near the border with Northern Ireland. The suspect is a law student, Isobella Perrie Sullivan, whom police believe was working for the New Irish Republican Army, a radical republican group that aims to overthrow British rule in Northern Ireland.Catherine, Princess of Wales and William, Prince of Wales during a visit to Northern Ireland on October 9, 2026 at Belfast. Mark Cuthbert/Getty ImagesMary Lou McDonald, leader of Sinn Féin, the party that serves as the repository for hopes of a united Ireland and has long been associated with the IRA, declared on Friday that Mr. Martin’s announcement marks “an opportunity we must seize. Preparations must now move forward with urgency, with the resources, ambition and inclusive approach needed to shape our shared future.” Sinn Féin’s motto is “Tiocfaidh ár lá,” or “our day will come,” a reference to the deferred dream of unification.Mr. Martin’s announcement comes a few months after the Irish journalist Paul Howard published his speculative — until now — fiction, “A Nation Once Again.” The novel imagines how a career diplomat, Fiach O’Bric, is “strong-armed into taking over a shadowy top-secret department tasked with preparing for a United Ireland — a job so surreal it makes his last posting, in Beijing, seem like a Buddhist retreat.”

Dublin Sets Planning for United Ireland in Motion on an Island Haunted by the ‘Troubles’

Dublin Sets Planning for United Ireland in Motion on an Island Haunted by the ‘Troubles’

More from the New York Sun

Albania’s Capital Burns Over a Kushner Resort as Prime Minister Rama Blames a ‘Hybrid War’

Syria Shuts Women Out of Military Colleges and Paints Headscarves Into Schoolbooks

Why Putin Has So Much Room To Maneuver in War Against Ukraine

Italian Courts Undermine Giorgia Meloni’s Efforts To Uphold Law and Order Amid Spate of Riots

Congo’s Former President, Sentenced to Death for Backing Rebels, Now Leads Them Toward Key Border City

Afghan Women Can’t Become Doctors and Male Doctors Are Told Not To Treat Them

Personalized Cancer Vaccine Cuts Melanoma Relapse Risk by 42 Percent in Landmark Trial

As Breeders’ Cup Crowns Its Champions, Repole Challenges Horse Racing’s Establishment

More from the New York Sun

Albania’s Capital Burns Over a Kushner Resort as Prime Minister Rama Blames a ‘Hybrid War’

Syria Shuts Women Out of Military Colleges and Paints Headscarves Into Schoolbooks

Why Putin Has So Much Room To Maneuver in War Against Ukraine

Italian Courts Undermine Giorgia Meloni’s Efforts To Uphold Law and Order Amid Spate of Riots

Congo’s Former President, Sentenced to Death for Backing Rebels, Now Leads Them Toward Key Border City

Afghan Women Can’t Become Doctors and Male Doctors Are Told Not To Treat Them

Personalized Cancer Vaccine Cuts Melanoma Relapse Risk by 42 Percent in Landmark Trial

As Breeders’ Cup Crowns Its Champions, Repole Challenges Horse Racing’s Establishment