Fauci’s Refusal To Answer Questions Matches Hubris of America’s Botched Response to Covid

The public health bureaucrat who became the face of America’s botched Covid-19 response, Dr. Anthony Fauci, testified this week on Capitol Hill. Except Dr. Fauci actually didn’t testify: In an astonishing act of hubris and disdain for the countless Americans who bore the brunt of tyrannical Covid-era “Faucism,” he invoked the Fifth Amendment well over 100 times.It’s an unprecedented defiance of congressional will for a man who has already received a sweeping presidential pardon. Congress would do well to vote to hold Dr. Fauci in contempt.Wednesday’s intense senatorial standoff followed Senator Rand Paul’s earlier release of damning excerpts of Dr. Fauci’s diary. Those excerpts disclosed a man obsessed with his burgeoning self-image. Dr. Fauci also harbored grave private doubts about many key Covid-era disputes, such as the virus’s hotly contested origins, on which the longtime National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases director otherwise projected a sense of confidence to a wary public.In short, this past week painted a villain-like picture of the figure who personified Covid hell for so many.In lecturing Americans to shut up and simply “trust the science,” Dr. Fauci committed the fallacy of scientism: He conflated science, or “science,” for the public good that statesmen are tasked with securing. Moreover, Dr. Fauci’s one-man reign of Covid-era biomedical terror served as a capstone on the century-long administrative state project of empowering would-be elites in Washington, D.C., over the judgments of the people.Thankfully, not every American was equally subjected to Dr. Fauci’s overweening, politically expedient and often-changing dictates. We have our Founders to thank for that: Federalism mitigated the burdens of Faucism for the many Americans fortunate enough to live in states whose political leadership defied prevailing COVID-era biomedical despotism.I would know: I moved to Florida in 2021 in no small part due to the way Governor Ron DeSantis handled Covid-19.Mr. DeSantis, alongside Republican leaders in the Florida Legislature, acted in heroic fashion during Covid. At a time when white coat tyranny raged and most Americans deferred to those who spoke in the name of “science,” Mr. DeSantis did the reading himself and concluded that the dissenters from groupthink orthodoxy, such as Great Barrington Declaration authors Jay Bhattacharya and Martin Kulldorff, were right: Covid-19 did not necessitate the draconian policy responses demanded by the biomedical clerisy.Accordingly, Florida under Mr. DeSantis fully opened its restaurants, bars and beaches in 2020, well before the feds said it was prudent to do so. Florida under Mr. DeSantis mandated that schools had to be open for in-person schooling in fall 2020. Florida under Mr. DeSantis blocked local governments, schools and private businesses from imposing Covid-19 vaccine mandates in fall 2021.More than any other state during the Covid era, Florida was freer and more open. For this, Dr. Fauci called Mr. DeSantis a “complete disgrace” in his now-exposed diary.Yet the joke is on Dr. Fauci. During the core Covid years of 2020-2022, the Faucian nemesis Sunshine State had an age-adjusted Covid mortality rate that ranked 31st in the nation. That’s well above average. Notably, many leading blue states that implemented harsh lockdowns and school closures, such as New York and New Jersey, fared considerably worse.Americans voted with their feet too: Florida recorded the largest annual net in-migration between July 2020 and July 2021, according to the Census Bureau. Florida, the once-iconic swing state that decided the 2000 presidential election by 537 votes, now boasts a Republican governor who won reelection by 19.4 percent and a Republican supermajority in both houses of its state legislature.None of this would have happened had Florida not assembled its own medical team and ignored Dr. Fauci and the feds. And Florida didn’t just vindicate itself with the voters and the science (if not the “science”). It also vindicated the Founders’ vision of federalism.One-size-fits-all bureaucratic governance from the nation’s capital is incompatible with American constitutionalism and the American way of life. As James Madison put it in 45 Federalist: “The powers … which are to remain in the State governments are numerous and indefinite.” Justice Louis D. Brandeis put it memorably in a 1932 Supreme Court dissent: “It is one of the happy incidents of the federal system that a single courageous State may, if its citizens choose, serve as a laboratory; and try novel social and economic experiments without risk to the rest of the country.”That’s exactly what Florida under Mr. DeSantis did.As for Dr. Fauci? He’s been reduced to ham-fisted legal stunts and temper tantrums. Creators.com

Fauci’s Refusal To Answer Questions Matches Hubris of America’s Botched Response to Covid

Fauci’s Refusal To Answer Questions Matches Hubris of America’s Botched Response to Covid

More from the New York Sun

Far Left’s Animus Toward America Faces Test in Midterm Voting

Trump Plans To Give Final Midterm Speech at the Reflecting Pool

Democrats Leading in All Seven Swing Senate Races 48 Hours Before Election Day: Poll

Few Will Lament the End of a Nasty and Disappointing Midterm Campaign

‘The Gilded Age’ Finds in Past Glories a Civilized Respite From Our Partisan Present

‘A Despicable Betrayal’: Democrats Pile on Stevens After Last-Minute Endorsement of Rogers in Michigan Senate Race

Principles Meet Reality as Israel’s Eisenkot Weighs Alliance With Arab Parties

The Winner on Tuesday

More from the New York Sun

Far Left’s Animus Toward America Faces Test in Midterm Voting

Trump Plans To Give Final Midterm Speech at the Reflecting Pool

Democrats Leading in All Seven Swing Senate Races 48 Hours Before Election Day: Poll

Few Will Lament the End of a Nasty and Disappointing Midterm Campaign

‘The Gilded Age’ Finds in Past Glories a Civilized Respite From Our Partisan Present

‘A Despicable Betrayal’: Democrats Pile on Stevens After Last-Minute Endorsement of Rogers in Michigan Senate Race

Principles Meet Reality as Israel’s Eisenkot Weighs Alliance With Arab Parties

The Winner on Tuesday