Hollywood Lawyers Are Distorting Justice in the Cornell Fraternity Case

The civil trial of the seven Cornell University fraternity men is already being turned into a media spectacle with almost no chance of fairness to the accused unless the court shuts down the theatrics, pronto.This is a case basically about the actions of eight college students, but it has an all-star cast of legal titans, with Thomas Giuffra lawyering for the female accuser. Mr. Giuffra has raked in millions of dollars representing women accusing Harvey Weinstein and Sean “Diddy” Combs of sexual assault.Mark Geragos, who has represented Combs, the NFL quarterback, Colin Kaepernick, and Hunter Biden, is acting as what Mr. Giuffra calls a “shadow member of the defense,” appearing on TMZ, while his daughter, Teny Geragos, an established lawyer in her own right, represents one of the accused.These big-shot lawyers are on the case because deep-pocket Cornell is also one of the defendants. Civil suits are about money, not sending anyone to jail.The accuser, Jane Doe, is firing off written statements to CNN and other press organizations claiming she was “raped” and “brutalized” in the Chi Phi fraternity house. Yet New York state law shields her with anonymity. Public officials can’t release her name unless the court orders it.The anonymous accuser is awash in accolades. Actress Florence Pugh called her “so unbelievably powerful” and “so strong willed.” Nonsense. There’s nothing powerful about hiding your identity instead of standing by your claims.Meanwhile the seven accused young men — all named in the complaint filed on September 16 — are being dragged through the mud; one has even gotten fired from his job. Mr. Giuffra could have omitted their names, calling them John Doe No. 1 through John Doe No. 7. Indeed, Mr. Giuffra spared certain Cornell faculty and administrators who are also defendants, calling them John Does. With the frat men, he went for the jugular.Last week, lawyers for one of the accused male students asked the court to put a stop to the trial by publicity “to ensure that the litigation occurs where it belongs, in the courtroom, rather than through an ongoing public relations campaign.” They warned of “improper influence upon the prospective juror pool.”The request cited examples of the accuser and her attorney asserting that she was incapable of consent and that defendants had engaged in a coverup and disposed of evidence, facts that should be established in a courtroom with witnesses cross-examined.The defense lawyers requesting the gag order asked that it be applied to both sides, an even-handed approach.On Friday, though, Judge Phaedra F. Perry-Bond summarily rejected the request, offering a lot of blather but no real substance. She claimed that the request is a “‘side show’ meant to muddy the waters and distract from the merits of the claims.” She added “there’s nothing stopping defendants from demonstrating through the course of litigation” that the statements made in the press are untrue. That’s like saying “the sky is blue.”The result is that the accuser is free to attack the defendants by name, but they are muzzled from naming her.The judge’s ruling leaves Mr. Giuffra free to continue playing the press like a fiddle. Even before filing the suit, he had provided information to a Cornell Daily Sun reporter, ensuring she was, in her own words, “really prepared” when the story broke.On Tuesday, Mr. Giuffra was at it again. The New York Times ran a front-page story about a letter from the accuser, delivered by Mr. Giuffra to the Cornell University Senate, asking the body to condemn the university administration for its inactions.He’s trying to get a judgment against Cornell in the court of public opinion before the trial even starts.This civil case is just beginning. There’s time to right the ship and provide justice. First, look for one of the defendants to request that the accuser be identified. Her active engagement with the press should automatically forfeit her right to anonymity.Secondly, pressure is building for the defendants to also face criminal charges and, if convicted, long prison sentences. But the decision should be made based on evidence, not politics.Ithaca’s district attorney, Matthew Van Houten, says criminal charges were not brought in 2024 because “nothing” in the accuser’s “original statement indicated she was drugged without consent or had sex against her will.” According to Mr. Van Houten, her statement to police in 2024 says that “each time” she “asked to stop the sexual conduct, the sexual conduct stopped.” These facts are omitted from the civil complaint.The accuser’s experience at the Chi Phi fraternity house was horrible. Yet a jury will decide who is responsible for the tragedy that night. That’s the American way — an impartial jury presented with the facts. Not Hollywood lawyers calling the shots on television.Creators.com

Hollywood Lawyers Are Distorting Justice in the Cornell Fraternity Case

Hollywood Lawyers Are Distorting Justice in the Cornell Fraternity Case

More from the New York Sun

Trump, Xi, Putin May Sit Down for Trilateral Summit in China on Sidelines of Gathering of Asia-Pacific Leaders

El-Sayed, Rogers Invoke Israel, Muslim Brotherhood as Proxies in Final Michigan Senate Race Debate

Times-Siena Poll Gives Democrats 11-Point Lead in Generic House Ballot in Final Midterm Survey

Democrats’ Mantra That ‘No One Is Above the Law’ Includes Ilhan Omar, Too

Ireland Warns Grandparents Against Hugging Their Grandchildren in New ‘Request Consent’ Campaign

‘La Bola Negra’ Boldly Reimagines a Spanish Love Story, Giving Lorca the Ending He Was Denied

Billy Crystal Swaps a Pity Party for a Broadway Valentine

F. Scott Fitzgerald’s ‘Benjamin Button’ Comes of Age on Stage

More from the New York Sun

Trump, Xi, Putin May Sit Down for Trilateral Summit in China on Sidelines of Gathering of Asia-Pacific Leaders

El-Sayed, Rogers Invoke Israel, Muslim Brotherhood as Proxies in Final Michigan Senate Race Debate

Times-Siena Poll Gives Democrats 11-Point Lead in Generic House Ballot in Final Midterm Survey

Democrats’ Mantra That ‘No One Is Above the Law’ Includes Ilhan Omar, Too

Ireland Warns Grandparents Against Hugging Their Grandchildren in New ‘Request Consent’ Campaign

‘La Bola Negra’ Boldly Reimagines a Spanish Love Story, Giving Lorca the Ending He Was Denied

Billy Crystal Swaps a Pity Party for a Broadway Valentine

F. Scott Fitzgerald’s ‘Benjamin Button’ Comes of Age on Stage